Buddy reported!

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I didn't see the incident. How bad is it?

[ScottH]

I didn't see the incident. How bad is it?

According to SEN, nothing in it. But you never know.

Bateman done a hamstring as well.

[Mike_B]

Having just seen it, it was not as bad as Goodes, so would expect to see an assessment of 4 activation points for a 75 point penalty, take the early plea and cop 56.25 carry-over pts.

[gossipcom]

Has Buddy been suspended in the past 12 months - trying to figure out if he's got any carry-over points that might throw him over to become ineligible for the Brownlow (that's if the Tribunal don't throw it out the window before Monday).

[Mike_B]

Has Buddy been suspended in the past 12 months - trying to figure out if he's got any carry-over points that might throw him over to become ineligible for the Brownlow (that's if the Tribunal don't throw it out the window before Monday).
Carryover points incurred last year but still active this year that would result in a suspension would not make him ineligible for the Brownlow.

There needs to be an assessment on a charge of over 100 points this year (before discounts) for a player to be ruled ineligible.

For instance, Goodes is ineligible coz he was charged with an offence at 125pts, but by taking the early plea, this gets reduced to 93.75pts meaning he doesn't miss a game.

[Big Al]

I thought it was at least a 3 week hit;)

[gossipcom]

There needs to be an assessment on a charge of over 100 points this year (before discounts) for a player to be ruled ineligible.
Gotcha. So if they deemed it to be over the 100 points and he had carry-over points but took an early guilty plea then technically he'd be ineligible for the Brownlow even if he didn't have enough to miss a game?

[Mike_B]

Gotcha. So if they deemed it to be over the 100 points and he had carry-over points but took an early guilty plea then technically he'd be ineligible for the Brownlow even if he didn't have enough to miss a gam?
Yep!

[AnnieH]

Noooooooooooooooooo.
He and Goodesy are the only two keeping my dreamteam from total humilation!!

[ScottH]

Having just seen it, it was not as bad as Goodes, so would expect to see an assessment of 4 activation points for a 75 point penalty, take the early plea and cop 56.25 carry-over pts.

I think you may be right Mike, or even thrown out. The big difference between Goodes and Buddy is that Buddy's was front on where as Goodes was a "glancing" blow.

The player buddy hit was upright as he prepared for contact and fell at the last second causing the head high contact.

But the way the MRP works he could get anywhere between a slap on the wrist to 44 weeks.

[reigning premier]

Did the player get up and take the kick? If he did, well he'll probably end up with a reprimand only. I've only seen the replay once so I'll leave the detailed comments to others, but the fact that the player Goodes hit got up and took his kick saved Goodes from being out for a couple of weeks.

[573v30]

There wasn't much in it. It should be a reprimand given his good record but there was some front-on contact and will be looked at, no doubt.

[dimelb]

I thought similar to Goodes, 100+ points, discount and reprimand. But as Scott sys, who knows? Not us. Footy Show (the real one) agreed.

[Industrial Fan]

Nothing in it.

Shouldn't even be looked at.

[Reggi]

Similar to Goodes, may be deemed Reckless or medium, negligent most likely

[gossipcom]

He's been offered a reprimand 125 points.

Okay I think I've got this right (been up since 6am so am a tad out of it), since it goes with what Mike put above, that if Buddy accepts the reprimand with the discount, he'll be eligible to play next weekend but would be ineligible for the Brownlow because it was above the 100 points?

[Robbo]

It was a pretty soft report IMO. It's good that he won't miss any games over it.

[31 hard at it]

Yes. If he accepts and pleads guilty then he gets a 25% discount which drops the points to 93.75.

Gilty so no brownlow but under 100 so no match loss.

[Mike_B]

He's been offered a reprimand 125 points.

Okay I think I've got this right (been up since 6am so am a tad out of it), since it goes with what Mike put above, that if Buddy accepts the reprimand with the discount, he'll be eligible to play next weekend but would be ineligible for the Brownlow because it was above the 100 points?
Yep. Exact same situation as Goodesy.

[Industrial Fan]

Protected species or what?

[ugg]

LRT cleared of his bump on Hayes.

[TheGrimReaper]

Protected species or what?

Wonder what Matthews thinks of this? :confused:

[573v30]

Not much in it and got what it deserved, a reprimand if early guilty plea is taken.

Buddy = protected species. :p