• Round 10, 2011 - A win is a win!

    Sort of forgot about the report until Sunday morning. I usually take a note pad and get my PA to take notes for me. However, my PA is doing VCE, and chose not to come. Which was a good thing for all around us, as she is chocked up with cold at the moment.
    Many thanks to the people who chose to spend the afternoon with me. It made for some light entertainment from a rather frustrating and stressful game.
    The game:
    We started bad, North could not capitalise on it, missing some relatively easy shots. 7 scoring shots to zip, and they only led by 22. I don?t think the swans had gone too far forward of centre by this stage. Edwards and Petrie proving handy targets up forward. Ted was soon moved off the dangerous Petrie and replaced by Grundy, who did a stellar job to quell his early dominance up forward. Captain McVeigh broke the drought with set shot from just on 50. This was followed by a string of behinds to trail by 12 points.
    The deck was shuffled and re-dealt at ? time. The swans came out looking like they should have ? an hour earlier. If not for the Roos failed shots on goal, they would have kept their lead but the swans slowly pegged them back, and with a Hannebery shot looking like it might be touched on the line. Backman now Forward sometimes Ruckman, LRT sailed over the pack for a great pack mark, and kicked truly to put the swans in front for the first time in the game. It was the Roos turn to kick some score in Junk time, recapturing the lead, by 2 at the main break.
    3.4 and 2.6 to 1.4 and 4.4. Terrible kicking in perfect conditions under a roof.
    Again the swans came out firing, snared back the lead, only to cough it up again. But a goal to McGlynn after being cleaned up by the Much bigger Firrito, and then Lewis Johnston?s first AFL from outside 50 raised the bar for kicking straight. I think young Parker may have nightmares about his set shot at goal. 2.3 to 3.3 and the swans were back in front. It really was painful to watch. Just as one team looked to take some ascendancy, the other would strike back.
    Again the Roos failed to kick straight, even their captain was joining the behinds list.
    Queue one Lewis Jetta, pretty much his first touch of the footy after being subbed on for Parker, he had run into the pocket and had a shot which missed. But minutes later , he got the ball from a deft tap close on the boundary line and streaked forward as only he can and kicked to Goodes in the pocket who ran in and goaled to extend the lead to our biggest in the game. That was pretty much the end of our ascendancy period and the Roos then dominated with 5 minute burst of scoring, but poor kicking would let them down again. A free to McGlynn right in front saved the day, and the swans led by 1 point with about 10 minutes to go. In a remarkable display of defence, the Swans held out the determined Roos. A Petrie mark was disallowed after he copped Grundy high. What followed was 5 mins of desperate, desperate footy. No one really managed to get an effective disposal, and with plenty of tackling and smothering, it was all too reminiscent of a game in 2005, albeit for a lesser prize. Probably one of the best afield took what would be the last mark of the game, and Reg slowly ate up what he could of the clock before setting the ball on its way, as far as possible from the goals. Siren sounds. And we all start to breath again. Terrible game, terrible win, but we?ll take the 4 points. Umpiring was a bit schmitt.

    Player reviews
    Mark Seaby, I want my mummy back
    Rhyce Shaw, played the best game I?ve seen him play for a while. Another of the BOG?s
    Jarrad McVeigh, got plenty of the ball, had some very good moments, but fell down with the dropped ball running into goal.
    Dan Hannebery, a real trooper. Love the way he goes about his stuff. Had a great game.
    Ryan O'Keefe, like Mcveigh got plenty of the ball, but needs to capitalise on it with better usage.
    Nick Malceski, Lars Hair? get a decent haircut, and you?ll improve. Not as good as last week, but ?fair dinkum, unbelievable?!!
    Josh Kennedy, a real work horse, thought he struggled s bit, only 4 clearance, but who can?t love JPK.
    Craig Bird, I feel he is improve each game, his disposal is usually top notch, like an iron, warming slowly.
    Tadhg Kennelly, excellent game again, played the loose man with aplomb. Those skinny little legs worked overtime.
    Sam Reid, The boy can mark, and kick, just needs to get those set shots, and he?ll be a keeper!!
    Ben McGlynn, 3 goals, knocked from pillar to post. End of story. Good job.
    Lewis Johnston, poor guy, struggled at times, but kicked a lovely goal. You will get better!!
    Jude Bolton, The work horse. Much better game than last week, could?ve been unlucky with the umps, but ?
    Ted Richards, got killed in the first 5 mins by Petrie, but then went on to have a stellar game. I reckon he?s earned his Super Ted title back.
    Luke Parker, Run down in front of goal, probable not his fault entirely but a good learning incentive. Shocker kick for goal. Sorry to harp on the negatives, kid got 13 touches in his 3 game. I think he had Rawlings on him ast some stage too. Tough job.
    Martin Mattner, Marty, Marty you could have swallowed that ball, otherwise a terrific game.
    Lewis Roberts-Thomson, as a backman, he?s pretty darn good, should get Browny next week, As Forward he does OK, as Ruckman, umm no forget it, stick to what you know.
    Lewis Jetta, a little spark, a miss, a great goal assist to Goodes, and an even better tackle on a giant. We missed his speed earlier.
    Alex Johnson, and other good game from the young fellow. Showing great maturity.
    Adam Goodes, How many dropped marks? How many missed tackles? I think his mind is sometimes 3 plays ahead of his hands. Would make a great chess player.
    Heath Grundy, Dropped a few weeks back. But playing better than ever. Had his work cut out, but held on and didn?t panic. Saving game mark.
    Nick Smith, Shhh. No one knows who he is. Let?s keep it that way. He?s no good. Should be in the twos. Get rid of him. I love Smithy. In a manly way!!

    North Melbourne 3.4 5.10 7.13 9.17 (71)
    Sydney Swans 1.3 5.8 8.11 10.12 (72)

    North Melbourne: Petrie 3, Thompson 2, Edwards 2, Macmillan, Wells
    Sydney Swans: McGlynn 3, Goodes 2, Roberts-Thomson, Reid, McVeigh, Seaby, Johnston

    North Melbourne: Thompson, Swallow, Wells, Petrie, Adams, MacMillan, Goldstein
    Sydney Swans: Kennelly, Shaw, Grundy, Mattner, Hannebery, Malceski, McGlynn

    North Melbourne: Todd Goldstein (jarred elbow)
    Sydney Swans: None

    North Melbourne: Ben Cunnington replaced by Ben Speight at three quarter time
    Sydney Swans: Luke Parker replaced by Lewis Jetta two minutes into the fourth quarter

    Reports: Nil

    Umpires: Kennedy, Dalgleish, Schmitt

    Official crowd: 24,267 at Etihad Stadium
    Comments 10 Comments
    1. dimelb's Avatar
      dimelb -
      Thanks Scott. Good work, summed up the elation and the frustration.
    1. Kirkari's Avatar
      Kirkari -
      Nice work, Scott! That siren was music to every Swan's ears.

      Agreed re Nick Smith, except that I want to fight people who say he's no good.

      If Sammy can put on enough muscle to keep from hurting himself, even the stupidest Melbourne journo is going to know his name.
    1. ScottH's Avatar
      ScottH -
      OK. The Nick Smith comment was tongue in cheek. Just in case one of the other 16 clubs read it. We want to keep him a secret!!

      Sammy is going to be huge when he bulks up. He already has big shoulders, but with a few more k's on them and a heap of muscle, he'll be hard to stop.
    1. RogueSwan's Avatar
      RogueSwan -
      Bit harsh on Teddy, it was not his fault Petrie got the ball delivered on a platter in those opening minutes. No defender in the league would have stopped those marks.
      I agree with the comment on Eski's hair, it is a shocker.
    1. ScottH's Avatar
      ScottH -
      Not harsh, just stating the facts.
      And yes he did get good delivery, but Ted was about 10 steps behind.
    1. ugg's Avatar
      ugg -
      Scott, this article doesn't show up on the Mobile skin for some reason.
    1. ScottH's Avatar
      ScottH -
      Just this article, or others before it??
    1. Kirkari's Avatar
      Kirkari -
      Hey Scott - I got the tongue in cheek part (though the subtleties of sarcasm are lost on me very often, and look at how crap I am at using it!). Just meant that we'd like to keep him secret but then ALSO want to fight them for not being in on it. It's extremely complicated being inside my head... ;-)
    1. ScottH's Avatar
      ScottH -
      I think I got all that!! Just glad I'm not in there (head) with you. could be explosive.
      It is hard to type sarcasm, isn't it.

      Anyway, we both understand our position on Young Smithy!!
      You weren't the first one to comment on my NS review.
    1. ShockOfHair's Avatar
      ShockOfHair -
      Good review, great player assessments. For sure, LARS surgery on Melcho's hair.
  • #goswans Feed

Single Sign On provided by vBSSO