Trading talk thread

**robamiee** · 27th August 2009, 01:24 PM

i would be going for Deleido as well, he may like the idea of sydney and being out of the bubble that is Melb...

He is def worth the 450-500 mark per yr....
Has pace and can be the outside midfielder we desp need.....
Trade: Hall and Barlow for him....
maybe throw Abett in for good measure

**hammo** · 27th August 2009, 01:35 PM

Originally Posted by robamiee

i would be going for Deleido as well, he may like the idea of sydney and being out of the bubble that is Melb...

He is def worth the 450-500 mark per yr....
Has pace and can be the outside midfielder we desp need.....
Trade: Hall and Barlow for him....
maybe throw Abett in for good measure

Ridiculous. Unless you are prepared to give up a first round pick then forget about it.

We will not be giving up our first and second round picks in this draft.

**robamiee** · 27th August 2009, 01:37 PM

by all acounts the draft is not all that deep this year, i woiuld give a 2nd rounder for him...a known gun for someone with potential i know what i would be going for.....

**stellation** · 27th August 2009, 01:45 PM

Originally Posted by hammo

Ridiculous. Unless you are prepared to give up a first round pick then forget about it.

We will not be giving up our first and second round picks in this draft.

I'd give up the first round pick for him.

**Lucky Knickers** · 27th August 2009, 02:47 PM

I like Lids.

**Plugger46** · 27th August 2009, 03:49 PM

Originally Posted by stellation

I'd give up the first round pick for him.

So would I.

**Mr Magoo** · 27th August 2009, 03:54 PM

Being that Deledio is a number one draft pick with plenty of years ahead of him, I would have thought our first round pick would be a pretty fair trade and we would lose nothing from it.

My only reservation is that I have heard panelists on one of the footy shows discuss him once and they seemed to be of the opinion that he doesnt have the motor to play midfield. I dont know enough about him personally but that would concern me.

**robamiee** · 27th August 2009, 04:23 PM

Originally Posted by Mr Magoo

Being that Deledio is a number one draft pick with plenty of years ahead of him, I would have thought our first round pick would be a pretty fair trade and we would lose nothing from it.

My only reservation is that I have heard panelists on one of the footy shows discuss him once and they seemed to be of the opinion that he doesnt have the motor to play midfield. I dont know enough about him personally but that would concern me.

He is still young, so his endurance may come with time..What draft was he picked up in..
then again the Deleido option is really pure speculation based on media reports about his unhappiness..

**Hartijon** · 27th August 2009, 04:24 PM

Originally Posted by Mr Magoo

Being that Deledio is a number one draft pick with plenty of years ahead of him, I would have thought our first round pick would be a pretty fair trade and we would lose nothing from it.

My only reservation is that I have heard panelists on one of the footy shows discuss him once and they seemed to be of the opinion that he doesnt have the motor to play midfield. I dont know enough about him personally but that would concern me.

What a steal he would be for just first pick.I would throw in Ablett and Brabazon plus $500,000. He could be the new Williams and we have enough midfielders to give him a rest every now and then. Get him ,at all costs! And panelists on Footy Shows have to pretend to have inside information so i would not take anything they say seriously.

**Mr Magoo** · 27th August 2009, 04:44 PM

Originally Posted by robamiee

He is still young, so his endurance may come with time..What draft was he picked up in..
then again the Deleido option is really pure speculation based on media reports about his unhappiness..

2004 I believe.

**liz** · 27th August 2009, 04:48 PM

Originally Posted by Hartijon

What a steal he would be for just first pick.I would throw in Ablett and Brabazon plus $500,000.

I suspect the Tigers would be happier with just our first pick than clogging up their list with marginal (espec Brabazon) players. If they wanted Ablett, fair enough, but "added extras" usually devalue a deal, not add to it.