Whos going to play on judd?

[wolftone57]

Jack,LRT,Richards out of those three IMHO

LRT & Richards couldn't possibly play on Judd. for a start Judd is a mid-fielder & those two are essentially backmen, secondly he would burn them off in a mili-second. Jack has just returned from injury so his tank will not be as full as usual, so I propose Jack & Shaw share the duties. I wanted to see Shae on him last time when Horse left Ryno on him after Jack got injured. Ryno, great player that he is just doesn't have the pace for Judd & it takes away an attacking player as he is always trying to follow Judd.

[wolftone57]

I'd play Shaw on Murphy and Jack on Judd

Bird to Murphy

[wolftone57]

I expect Bird will go to Murphy and do a good job. Murphy looks the perfect matchup for Bird imo.

I think we need to try and just limit Judd if possible, he is near impossible to stop completely for a whole game.

Kizza has done good jobs on him (Qtr 1 this year, first half EF last year) and been towelled by him (Q3 EF last year)

Joey the same, did a brilliant last qtr job to quell the Judd influence in Q4 of the EF last year after Judd threatened to rip it away single handedly, yet Judd did win it single handedly this year in Q4 leaving Joey/ROK in his wake.

Murphy has been every bit as dangerous as Judd this year. Throw Bird on him and leave him there, provided Murphy doesn't get on top of course.

Sorry but ROK was on him until it was too late, late in the last, before being moved.

Jack & Shaw to doulbe on Judd
Bird on Murphy
The rest will virtually take care of themselves as these are the two we have to get right. Brice Gibbs will get Goodsie so we should see how big a motor he's got by giving Goodsie a lot of time in the mid field or giving him a lisence to roam all around the ground. Bryce likes to attack off half back & set play up that way, his father was the same (a great back pocket for Glenelg). He is a strong mark for his size just like his old man, strong body! run him around as he is not as comfortable being run around.

[wolftone57]

Goodes.

We have no one to stop Judd. Leat playing Goodes on Judd means we can hurt them the other way.

Ratton will not allow Goodes on Judd & it would be a disaster anyway. He will send Gibbs to Goodsie no matter what.

[Captain]

Ratton will not allow Goodes on Judd & it would be a disaster anyway. He will send Gibbs to Goodsie no matter what.

Not sure about this. Confused as to who it would be a diaster for?

[ugg]

Ratton will not allow Goodes on Judd & it would be a disaster anyway.

My SuperCoach team likes this matchup.

[wolftone57]

Not sure about this. Confused as to who it would be a diaster for?

You need a tagger on Judd. I remember a few matches when clubs havew said we have no-one to go with him so we will put our best on him & he racked up between 38 & 45 posies. You can't let him just go his own way & Goodsie, while a great player, is not quick enough & he would play Judd in a shoot out. It would also hurt Goodsies game if he were asked to go defensive, just like it did ROK. This would be disastrous for us & we would have a similar situation we had last time where ROK couldn't keep up with Judd as goodsie is too slow for him.

[ernie koala]

Give McVeigh the job, it's about time he produced a captains knock.
On his day, he is capable of hurting with goals the other way.
He's done it on Judd in the past.
If that doesn't work out, then Jack is the obvious candidate.

[Cheer_Cheer]

I reckon Smith would do a good job on Judd.. Then put Shaw on Betts..

[sfan]

I would give Shaw the job. Defender with pace in needed. Run with role could work quite well.

[Jewels]

Give McVeigh the job, it's about time he produced a captains knock.
On his day, he is capable of hurting with goals the other way.
He's done it on Judd in the past.
If that doesn't work out, then Jack is the obvious candidate.

Hear, hear!

[ScottH]

Hear, hear!

+1