I was thinking the same thing, we have had a lot of fantastic individual players over the club's history - I will have to re-visit that Team of the Century again, but as good as O'Loughlin was I suspect it would be pretty hard for him to outshine someone already in the team.
Of course it all depends on how you select your team - does team balance come into it, individual performances in a season, longevity, etc?
Bookmarks