Gary Rohan

[56-14]

& goes to Collingwood? That'd be yet another reason for me to hate the Pies!

When Barry jumped ship years ago, he initially went to Carlton, then Collingwood.
Chip off the old block?

[Mug Punter]

I think Towers for Daniel McStay of Brisbane would be a good swap and beneficial to all parties.

Towers could have a breakout run from now on and hold his spot through the finals although he hasn't shown the ability to string more than 1 or 2 good games together. 3 important games coming up and good opportunity to show his worth.

I like Towers but I think that Brisbane would be a really good destination for him. I'd think we'd probably need to offer something else even if it was just a swap of our second rounder for their third rounder or throwing in our third round pick which we probably won't use this year but which they may use for academy points

[goswannies]

When Barry jumped ship years ago, he initially went to Carlton, then Collingwood.
Chip off the old block?

I think you'll find Barry joined Collingwood from the Swans in 1993, and then the following year went to Carlton

[Ludwig]

I like Towers but I think that Brisbane would be a really good destination for him. I'd think we'd probably need to offer something else even if it was just a swap of our second rounder for their third rounder or throwing in our third round pick which we probably won't use this year but which they may use for academy points

I see McStay a bit like Towers, not in how they play, but how they've both performed below expectations. Towers was a pick 22 and McStay a pick 25 in the following year. Brisbane have added some good KPP prospects in recent years and will get tall utility academy player Jacob Allison, rated a 1st round prospect, this draft. McStay is not an automatic pick for a fairly weak Brisbane team. I was hoping that he could improve with our superior development program and is probably a good positional swap for both parties. Just speculation, but something that I would be looking at if I were the Swans list manager.

[ScottH]

I don't like the idea of having McStay and McVeigh in the same team.

[goswannies]

I don't like the idea of having McStay and McVeigh in the same team.

You want McVeigh to McWay for McStay?

[ScottH]

You want McVeigh to McWay for McStay?

[barry]

You want McVeigh to McWay for McStay?

McYes

[jono2707]

I don't like the idea of having McStay and McVeigh in the same team.

Do we make a play for Jack Macrae?

[stevoswan]

I see Gary looks like he's going nowhere.......this today on afl.com.au: Speedster Rohan quick to rubbish talk of leaving Swans - AFL.com.au

[Mug Punter]

I see Gary looks like he's going nowhere.......this today on afl.com.au: Speedster Rohan quick to rubbish talk of leaving Swans - AFL.com.au

I'd be very surprised if he was to leave and I doubt we'd get an offer to good to refuse, it would be an opportunistic move by the Cats and I couldn't see us getting more than a second rounder.

[stevoswan]

Yes, happily it now seems a moot point.