The Herald Sun Player Ratings scored Macca a 7, the same as Smithy, Hanners, NS, Jack and Heeney. However, Travis King on AFL.com scored him a 4 along with Buddy, Laidler and Papley! A lowly 3 for McGlynn, KT, Richards and Hewett with Rohan a 2 (which was very harsh). There were a few very strange ratings on both lists but how does Travis King explain the fact that we were neck and neck with the Doggies until the last few minutes of the game if 9 of our players didn't rate a pass mark! Not very credible.