2007 Scorecard - #48 Kieren Jack

[AnnieH]

Rate away ...

[ScottH]

5.5/10 Showed just enough.

[Lucky Knickers]

3/10 + 1 for effort and potential
= 4/10

[AnnieH]

4/10 ... for getting himself involved in controversy without first playing an actual senior game.

Is that a record? I'll bet that it is. :rofl

[Jewels]

5/10

Got a soft spot for the little fella and I reckon he'll come good.

[Triple B]

Have faith, he's a gun.

Just about all the regular magoo watchers rate him. Those who have barely seen him play and want to rate him on his senior appearance, at a time when our team across the board was as dysfunctional as they have been in the past 3 seasons, dismiss him at your peril.

Mark my words.

[2005]

Have faith, he's a gun.

Just about all the regular magoo watchers rate him. Those who have barely seen him play and want to rate him on his senior appearance, at a time when our team across the board was as dysfunctional as they have been in the past 3 seasons, dismiss him at your peril.

Mark my words.

Our Magoos isnt up to AFL standard.
Our local Eastern League is better than the Canberra League
We would be middle rung in the VFL if that believe me, so its not a great guide to read from even though that is all we can access our ducks from.Though agree with the point that Keiran will be OK, surely has to start in front of Bevan at the start of the year.
Your right the game against North , we were so bad it was very hard to see what he had.
Highly regarded upstairs though, I think he will make it as well
1/10

[BeeEmmAre]

The kid can play, and I look forward to seeing him do it on a more regular basis.
And I don't think he was that bad in the games he did play before returning to the rookie list either.
Plenty of potential and for a rookie to get a game, that proves he had a good season for me.

6/10.

[bennyfrou]

Will be in my Dreamteam early next year so when he starts playing and being a star I've picked him up cheaply :)

5/10 for potential and effort

[573v30]

4/10 - Has potential and will show us what he's got this season.

[Claret]

4/10 ... for getting himself involved in controversy without first playing an actual senior game.

Is that a record? I'll bet that it is. :rofl

Ask Sharrod Wellingham

[Zlatorog]

5/10

I hope he'll live up to the hype.

[Nico]

0/10 - can't agree on his potential, just another muppett type player to me.

Sloppy and cant kick.

I'll still jump on his bandwagon if he starts to shine, but until then ......

[Robbo]

Showed a little bit of potential, but so did Paul Bevan in 2004.

The two seem quite similar. Both from Thugby backgrounds and lack skill.

The jury is still well and truly out on him.

5/10

[Big Al]

I liked watching his dad play. 6/10

[reigning premier]

3/10....

Really has done nothing. The games he did play were average at best and he failed to be selected even when he was available (Rightfully slow).

May make the grade, but probably not. Besides, we need another smothering, suffocating type player like I need another leg....

[BeeEmmAre]

Kieren Jack scorecard

5.5, 4, 4, 5, 1, 6, 5, 4, 5, 0, 5, 6, 3

Total score = 53.5/130

Average = 4.12/10

Jack fails.