2006 Grand Final team

[Number 43]

Just curious. Who played in the 2006 Grand Final but didn't play and get a premiership medal in either 2005 or 2012?

[neilfws]

Pretty sure that only Stephen Doyle played in 2006 but neither of 2005 or 2012.

EDIT: actually, this has come up before (http://www.redandwhiteonline.com/forum/showthread.php/35498-Stephen-Doyle).

[Zlatorog]

Agree.

[ScottH]

Correct.

2005|2006|2012
Ablett, Luke |Ablett, Luke 2005|Bird, Craig
Ball, Jason |Barry, Leo 2005|Bolton, Jude
Barry, Leo |Bolton, Craig 2005|Goodes, Adam
Bevan, Paul |Bolton, Jude 2005/2012|Grundy, Heath
Bolton, Craig |Buchanan, Amon 2005|Hannebery, Dan
Bolton, Jude |Davis, Nick 2005|Jack, Kieren
Buchanan, Amon |Dempster, Sean 2005|Jetta, Lewis
Crouch, Jared |Doyle, Stephen -|Johnson, Alex
Davis, Nick |Fosdike, Nic 2005|Kennedy, Josh
Dempster, Sean |Goodes, Adam 2005/2012|Malceski, Nick
Fosdike, Nic |Hall, Barry 2005|Mattner, Martin
Goodes, Adam |Jolly, Darren 2005|McVeigh, Jarrad
Hall, Barry |Kennelly, Tadhg 2005|Morton, Mitch
Jolly, Darren |Kirk, Brett 2005|Mumford, Shane
Kennelly, Tadhg |Malceski, Nick 2012|OKeefe, Ryan
Kirk, Brett |Mathews, Ben 2005|Parker, Luke
Mathews, Ben |McVeigh, Jarrad 2012|Pyke, Mike
OKeefe, Ryan |OKeefe, Ryan 2005/2012|Reid, Sam
OLoughlin, Michael |OLoughlin, Michael 2005|Richards, Ted
Roberts-Thomson, Lewis |Richards, Ted 2012|Roberts-Thomson, Lewis
Schneider, Adam |Roberts-Thomson, Lewis 2005/2012|Shaw, Rhyce
Williams, Paul |Schneider, Adam 2005|Smith, Nick

[Swansongster]

Correct.

2005|2006|2012
Ablett, Luke |Ablett, Luke 2005|Bird, Craig
Ball, Jason |Barry, Leo 2005|Bolton, Jude
Barry, Leo |Bolton, Craig 2005|Goodes, Adam
Bevan, Paul |Bolton, Jude 2005/2012|Grundy, Heath
Bolton, Craig |Buchanan, Amon 2005|Hannebery, Dan
Bolton, Jude |Davis, Nick 2005|Jack, Kieren
Buchanan, Amon |Dempster, Sean 2005|Jetta, Lewis
Crouch, Jared |Doyle, Stephen -|Johnson, Alex
Davis, Nick |Fosdike, Nic 2005|Kennedy, Josh
Dempster, Sean |Goodes, Adam 2005/2012|Malceski, Nick
Fosdike, Nic |Hall, Barry 2005|Mattner, Martin
Goodes, Adam |Jolly, Darren 2005|McVeigh, Jarrad
Hall, Barry |Kennelly, Tadhg 2005|Morton, Mitch
Jolly, Darren |Kirk, Brett 2005|Mumford, Shane
Kennelly, Tadhg |Malceski, Nick 2012|OKeefe, Ryan
Kirk, Brett |Mathews, Ben 2005|Parker, Luke
Mathews, Ben |McVeigh, Jarrad 2012|Pyke, Mike
OKeefe, Ryan |OKeefe, Ryan 2005/2012|Reid, Sam
OLoughlin, Michael |OLoughlin, Michael 2005|Richards, Ted
Roberts-Thomson, Lewis |Richards, Ted 2012|Roberts-Thomson, Lewis
Schneider, Adam |Roberts-Thomson, Lewis 2005/2012|Shaw, Rhyce
Williams, Paul |Schneider, Adam 2005|Smith, Nick

At the risk of provoking debate and I know we have discussed it before but when you look at three teams in this table, I think 2012 team would prevail in a three-way round robin. The forward line with Magic and BBBH is perhaps a tad stronger than what we trotted out this year but elsewhere, across the paddock and onto the pines, our reigning premiers would be way ahead for mine.

[Alan]

Who were the emergencies for 05 & 06?

[ScottH]

Who were the emergencies for 05 & 06?

Malceski was one in 2005.

[Number 43]

Malceski was one in 2005.
I think Spriggs was an emergency in 06?

[Bloody Hell]

Dejavu

[ScottH]

Malceski was one in 2005.

Schauble and Vogels were the only other 2 on the list in the Record that didn't play.

Does anyone have the 2006 GF record?
I must've turfed mine.

[Alan]

I think McVeigh was also one in 2006

[goswannie14]

Schauble and Vogels were the only other 2 on the list in the Record that didn't play.

Does anyone have the 2006 GF record?
I must've turfed mine.I have mine, but it is still in the plastic and I'm hoping to get some dollars off a WCE supporter on Ebay!

[Triple B]

I think McVeigh was also one in 2006

He played.

[ugg]

2005: Malceski, Schauble, Vogels
2006: Bevan, Spriggs, Vogels

I didn't realise Vogels was emergency for both.

[Primmy]

Vogels good enough to be emergency but...... where is he now?

[ugg]

Full teams

2005
B: Crouch, Barry, Roberts-Thomson
HB: Mathews, C.Bolton, Kennelly
C: Dempster, Goodes, Buchanan
HF: O'Keefe, Hall, J.Bolton
F: Williams, O'Loughlin, Davis
Foll: Jolly, Kirk, Ablett

Int: Ball, Bevan, Schneider, Fosdike
Emg: Malceski, Schauble, Vogels


2006
B: Malceski, Barry, Richards
HB: C.Bolton, Roberts-Thomson, Kennelly
C: Ablett, Kirk, Buchanan
HF: J.Bolton, O'Loughlin, O'Keefe
F: Mathews, Hall, Schneider
Foll: Jolly, Goodes, McVeigh

Int: Davis, Dempster, Doyle, Fosdike
Emg: Bevan, Spriggs, Vogels


Changes from 05 to 06
In: Doyle, Malceski, McVeigh, Richards
Out: Ball, Bevan, Crouch, Williams

[ScottH]

Changes from 05 to 06
In: Doyle, Malceski, McVeigh, Richards
Out: Ball, Bevan, Crouch, Williams

No wonder we lost in 2006, that is a lot of experience and skill missing, compared to the ins at the time.
And then there is Bevan.

[Alan]

There were huge raps on Spriggs when he came to us

[Frog]

Vogels good enough to be emergency but...... where is he now?

From an article in June of 2010 ...

He now plays for East Ringwood. He had a quiet game as East Ringwood lost to South Croydon at the weekend, but his legacy to potential AFL players remains.
Read more : AFL clubs cast net far and wide in search of that special talent (http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-clubs-cast-net-far-and-wide-in-search-of-that-special-talent-20100608-xtnr.html)