which club did the best trading?

[dread and might]

has to be freo for me. gave away draft picks, but two super midfielders, lots of talented youth anyway.......

i know that neither carr nor black were ever on the radar for sydney, but:mad:

[Bleed Red Blood]

Hawthorn, in the long term anyway.They won't have a forward line next year, but they have some quality youth coming to the club.

Freo did do well.But lost a tall for a small.

Melbourne did well.

[Mike_B]

Richmond didn't do too badly either. In effect got Simmonds for Ottens plus a couple of extra first round picks.

[Damien]

Originally posted by Mike_B
Richmond didn't do too badly either. In effect got Simmonds for Ottens plus a couple of extra first round picks.

Yep, Richmond, they lost Ottens who hadn't performed for them for 2 years anyway, gained Simmonds and have 5 picks in the Top 20.

Looking good for Plough's five year contract.

[thehalford]

Hawthorn easily. Freo did terribly. No way is Josh Carr worth what they paid. Black for Simmonds isn't too bad though...

[dread and might]

i think that freo would be happy considering port wanted Pav or hasleby. i know they were just "playing hardball" but i think freo will have the biggest noticable advantage next season. good points on the longer term advantages though.......

[cruiser]

I reckon Freo overall, with Geelong getting the best available (Ottens).