"ANZ Stadium has no atmosphere"

[Wardy]

Quite understandable that injuries were caused in all the excitement!! - I was perhaps a little excited for his goal too I've been waiting for 5 games and what an awesome goal - It was "the moment" of the Swans/Geelong game on the AFL's 8 moments this week too!!!!

yes I jumped up out of my seat and did the same thing - the people who were with me (all Geelong supporters in the blue and white gear) couldnt quite understand my excitement - I explained it was the kids first goal - they then stood and applauded him too.

[alison.z]

During our standing ovation for Hanners, I accidently hit the lady in front of me in the head. She just doesn't get it!!!

Quite understandable that injuries were caused in all the excitement!! - I was perhaps a little excited for his goal too I've been waiting for 5 games and what an awesome goal - It was "the moment" of the Swans/Geelong game on the AFL's 8 moments this week too!!!!

[Go Swannies]

During our standing ovation for Hanners, I accidently hit the lady in front of me in the head. She just doesn't get it!!!

Annie - are you Barry Hall?

In any case claim incidental contact and that it was in play.

[AnnieH]

After Hanners kicked his goal to put us in front the atmosphere really lifted and was pretty great for the rest of the night ... the size of the crowd has nothing to do with the atmosphere - the North final with 19-odd thousand was one of the most atmospheric games i've been to!!

During our standing ovation for Hanners, I accidently hit the lady in front of me in the head. She just doesn't get it!!!

[pinkemu]

I've noticed the same thing happens at the MCG in the Olympic Stand, to my surprise. The higher you go, the more the boundary line is eclipsed.

and if your on the lower section undercover close to the goals you can't see the top half of the goals.

[pinkemu]

The same happens at Docklands if you are sitting in the top tier. Can't see the boundary line in front of you. However, IMO,that pales into insignificance compared with what Dave is commenting on...having poles blocking your view in the middle of the ground.

Ahhh but it's a beautifull old stand.

[Wardy]

Anyone that has seen my seats at the SCG (Front section of Brewongle stand opposite the Centre Bounce) will understand why I prefer the SCG. Their is no equivalent viewing angle for me at Homebush. They seat me on Level 4 which is too high compared to the SCG and and Level 1 is too low.

As for the atmosphere debate, I still believe the SCG to be superior but do concede that the perception of atmosphere is an individual thing and everyone will have a different view.

if you can keep your seats at the SCG - then get a members reserve passes in the Red Zone where we sit at ANZ Northern end - about 30 rows up behind the goals - fantastic spot! (and only 15 paces from the bar, 30 paces to the loos) we like it!

[Big Al]

Anyone that has seen my seats at the SCG (Front section of Brewongle stand opposite the Centre Bounce) will understand why I prefer the SCG. Their is no equivalent viewing angle for me at Homebush. They seat me on Level 4 which is too high compared to the SCG and and Level 1 is too low.

As for the atmosphere debate, I still believe the SCG to be superior but do concede that the perception of atmosphere is an individual thing and everyone will have a different view.

[Lohengrin]

On TV, Homebush is a better spectacle than the SCG, except for the poor surface.

[Cheer Squad]

The same happens at Bocklands if you are sitting in the top tier. Can't see the boundary line in front of you. However, IMO,that pales into insignificance compared with what Dave is commenting on...having poles blocking your view in the middle of the ground.

I've noticed the same thing happens at the MCG in the Olympic Stand, to my surprise. The higher you go, the more the boundary line is eclipsed.

[goswannie14]

I can't see 1/3 of the boundary line on the eastern side of Swamplands and I'm in a premium seat.

The same happens at Docklands if you are sitting in the top tier. Can't see the boundary line in front of you. However, IMO,that pales into insignificance compared with what Dave is commenting on...having poles blocking your view in the middle of the ground.

[Cheer Squad]

I can't see 1/3 of the boundary line on the eastern side of Swamplands and I'm in a premium seat.

What's your bay and row number?

[magic.merkin]

being a victorian commenting on TV viewing, I think we give away to much of an advantage being there.

[pinkemu]

I have to agree with you. I've watched the club play just about everywhere, and it's pretty obvious the SCG has fallen way behind every other major sporting venue in the country. It certainly has the worst obstructed viewing area problem of any venue in the country, and your observations about the Trust's attitude is spot on.

I can't see 1/3 of the boundary line on the eastern side of Swamplands and I'm in a premium seat.

[Wardy]

There are so many factors to consider with regard to "atmosphere". But first and foremost, atmosphere is created by the reaction to whats actually happening on the ground in front of you. If its a high scoring game with twists and turns, exhilerating passages of play, and has you on the edge of your seat - then you & the rest of the crowd respond too it accordingly with passion and noise. If its a crap, low scoring game with continual stoppages etc, then the atmosphere is different again, it is almost a lethargic mood swing.

Whilst comfort & facilties at a venue certainly help you enjoy the occassion - it kind of takes a back seat to whats actually happening on the ground.

Most of us on here have all been fortunate enough to witness some fantastic games at both ANZ and the SCG in Sydney, and of course the majestic MCG & Dome in Melbourne - some games have been absolute ball breaking rippers, others have been like a couple of hours of having your teeth pulled and those hours are lost forever. It happens.