If Judd wasnt in the Carlton team friday night would they have won ?

[Auntie.Gerald]

For me I dont think they would have !

So that made me think firstly Carlton spent a lot of coin on Chris but it was a great decision and worth every penny.

It felt like against Geelong Chapman was the difference that sparked the final term and against Carlton Judd was the difference and on both occasion only in the final qtr

So are we just one marque player short of other teams or two at least ?

[swansrule100]

yeh but you take say goodes out of our side then how would we go say against the eagles round 3. We lost end of story. I think judd was great but i think he has some mates flying under the radar.

[ScottH]

Or Betts,

Or if Jack hadn't rolled his ankle.

Or if it had kept raining.

yada yada yada

[goswannie14]

Or Betts,

Or if Jack hadn't rolled his ankle.

Or if it had kept raining.

yada yada yada

Or if the interchange stupid had half a brain.

[Big Al]

Or if Mum had a headache 42 years ago I may not have cared who won...

[BSA5]

Honestly, no. Judd won that game for them. However, he was in the side, and we couldn't negate his influence, so it doesn't really matter.

[Nich]

or if mum had a headache 42 years ago i may not have cared who won...

:d

[CJK]

He was bloody good. Let's get him in our team.

[msb]

Yes we would of won IMO. What judd does for carlton is just unbelievable, when he gets that vital handball or kick that results in a goal (ie forward pocket the other night when the ball should of gone out of bounds) or crucial passage of play and the blues players then lift from that. It was the same against the crows last week, he won that game for carlton against them as well, they would be nowhere without judd.

[Mountain Man]

If Bevan was in their team............... would they have won?

[goswannie14]

If Bevan was in their team............... would they have won?

Well.....we would have had one more goal because he would have given us one, they would have had one less goal from his stuff up and the interchange stupids decision would be overturned and we would have won!!!

[GongSwan]

Without Judd they would look pretty ordinary, what he did in the final term was unbelievable, but considering Jack had him under control til he turned his ankle, and someone let Betts off the chain, I don't know, we had a few passengers in that game, but overall, I'd say no, without Judd, we probably win