Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 12 of 23

Thread: Vale Geoffrey Edelsten

  1. #1

    Vale Geoffrey Edelsten

    Sad to hear of the passing today of Dr Geoffrey Edelsten.

  2. #2
    Travelling Swannie!! mcs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Canberra
    Posts
    7,800
    Hard to know how history is going to look back on him, nor how we as Swans fans should consider his time owning the Swans.

    But as with the passing of anyway, RIP Geoffrey - we all have our qualities and our faults, and he was no different in that regard. And while the legacy of his time at the swans is a matter for open judgement, it is an important part of our history.
    "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

  3. #3
    Senior Player
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Sunshine Coast
    Posts
    1,548
    He was the man who helped create plenty of awareness of the Swans when he first became the “ owner “ of the Swans.
    His flair for publicity was the perfect fit for a club struggling to gain a foothold in their new home. He was also responsible for getting Tommy Haley to the club which helped us pick up some absolute star players in the mid 80’s . It’s still a matter of conjecture how we could have gone if finals matches were allocated the way they are now rather than having to be played in Victoria,
    Love him or loath him he made sure Sydney knew about us.

  4. #4
    Geoff did a power of Good for the swans, and as time goes on, his standing only improves.

  5. #5
    Senior Player
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Inner West
    Posts
    2,402
    A slightly odd character but no doubt his involvement with the club helped raise awareness of footy in Sydney and that was a good thing.

  6. #6
    Senior Player
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Inner West
    Posts
    2,402
    The other side to the Geoff of course is that he was one of the pioneers in warp speed Medicare billing that has now been
    corporatized that we're all paying for now through our taxes. But I guess if it wasn't him and his mates back in the day,
    someone else would have thought of it...

  7. #7
    Ego alta, ergo ictus Ruck'n'Roll's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Over here!
    Posts
    3,854
    I've been thinking about this since Friday arvo when I heard.

    Given that he was little more than a short term figurehead (less than a year), he had almost no actual investment in the club. The money, such as it was, came from Powerplay (or at least those that Powerplay could acquire money from).
    So was their any significance to his involvement? Can any achievements, problems really be ascribed to him?

    The previous posters assume we can. So let's look at the whole picture.

    On Field
    The frankly deranged recruitment drive over the 85-86 off season certainly did bring us a lot of wins. Which we all enjoyed.
    However salary cap issues, and the parlous state of Powerplay's finances played havok with our list management. After that first off season our recruiting quickly went from bad, through worse to grotesque - and next thing you know we'd lost 26 games in a row.
    If we credit him for bringing Hafey, Williams, Healy and Co then we also have remember Capper, Hawke, Tim Barling, Craig Davis, Darren Morgan, Wayne Caey and the rest. On balance we're talking a huge debit.

    Promotion
    Yes he created plenty of awareness, but the attendance figures were as genuine as a $3 bill. Almost every kid playing underage aussie rules, including my kid brothers, could access free tickets. I on the other hand had to have a meal at Hungry Jacks in order to get my free double passes.
    And then when the wins dried up, what value was all that promotion. We had even less people in the crowd than before the VFL sold the Swans to him, the Swans were still buying a half page in the Tele just to get some attention. I see no credit's there.

    Character
    His tattoo removal business, "colourful" business associates and bankruptcies - his character raises more red flags than the National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party. Hell the AMA de-registered him, and they're renowned for looking after their own. All up a most insalubrious character.

    The last word
    The simple truth is that he was never really a Swans man. A Carlton member both before and after his brief period at the Swans. In his later years, he attested to this true allegiance and remarked that he only purchased the Swans because the blue bags weren't up for sale.
    Loose translation from the Latin is - I am tall, so I hit out.

  8. #8
    Senior Player
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Close to the old Lake Oval
    Posts
    3,891
    Quote Originally Posted by Ruck'n'Roll View Post
    I've been thinking about this since Friday arvo when I heard.

    Given that he was little more than a short term figurehead (less than a year), he had almost no actual investment in the club. The money, such as it was, came from Powerplay (or at least those that Powerplay could acquire money from).
    So was their any significance to his involvement? Can any achievements, problems really be ascribed to him?

    The previous posters assume we can. So let's look at the whole picture.

    On Field
    The frankly deranged recruitment drive over the 85-86 off season certainly did bring us a lot of wins. Which we all enjoyed.
    However salary cap issues, and the parlous state of Powerplay's finances played havok with our list management. After that first off season our recruiting quickly went from bad, through worse to grotesque - and next thing you know we'd lost 26 games in a row.
    If we credit him for bringing Hafey, Williams, Healy and Co then we also have remember Capper, Hawke, Tim Barling, Craig Davis, Darren Morgan, Wayne Caey and the rest. On balance we're talking a huge debit.

    Promotion
    Yes he created plenty of awareness, but the attendance figures were as genuine as a $3 bill. Almost every kid playing underage aussie rules, including my kid brothers, could access free tickets. I on the other hand had to have a meal at Hungry Jacks in order to get my free double passes.
    And then when the wins dried up, what value was all that promotion. We had even less people in the crowd than before the VFL sold the Swans to him, the Swans were still buying a half page in the Tele just to get some attention. I see no credit's there.

    Character
    His tattoo removal business, "colourful" business associates and bankruptcies - his character raises more red flags than the National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party. Hell the AMA de-registered him, and they're renowned for looking after their own. All up a most insalubrious character.

    The last word
    The simple truth is that he was never really a Swans man. A Carlton member both before and after his brief period at the Swans. In his later years, he attested to this true allegiance and remarked that he only purchased the Swans because the blue bags weren't up for sale.
    Beautifully summarized

  9. #9
    Senior Player
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Sunshine Coast
    Posts
    1,548
    Quote Originally Posted by Blood Fever View Post
    Beautifully summarized
    Agreed great summary and pretty accurate I don’t think though that acknowledging his efforts however brief and short term they were is unwarranted.
    No one was suggesting life membership or a statue at the SCG 😀

  10. #10
    Pre G. Edelsten, it was pretty hard to find a Doc after 5.00pm for a sick person, he established Medical Centres that soon became a service ( opened by many others) all over the place that stayed opened for much longer hours.

  11. #11
    Many people are very keen to see a bulk billing Dr

    He pioneered pathology service

    The Vale on the Swans website was an “interesting” tribute
    Last edited by 0918330512; 12th June 2021 at 10:52 PM.

  12. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by Ruck'n'Roll View Post
    I've been thinking about this since Friday arvo when I heard.

    Given that he was little more than a short term figurehead (less than a year), he had almost no actual investment in the club. The money, such as it was, came from Powerplay (or at least those that Powerplay could acquire money from).
    So was their any significance to his involvement? Can any achievements, problems really be ascribed to him?

    The previous posters assume we can. So let's look at the whole picture.

    On Field
    The frankly deranged recruitment drive over the 85-86 off season certainly did bring us a lot of wins. Which we all enjoyed.
    However salary cap issues, and the parlous state of Powerplay's finances played havok with our list management. After that first off season our recruiting quickly went from bad, through worse to grotesque - and next thing you know we'd lost 26 games in a row.
    If we credit him for bringing Hafey, Williams, Healy and Co then we also have remember Capper, Hawke, Tim Barling, Craig Davis, Darren Morgan, Wayne Caey and the rest. On balance we're talking a huge debit.

    Promotion
    Yes he created plenty of awareness, but the attendance figures were as genuine as a $3 bill. Almost every kid playing underage aussie rules, including my kid brothers, could access free tickets. I on the other hand had to have a meal at Hungry Jacks in order to get my free double passes.
    And then when the wins dried up, what value was all that promotion. We had even less people in the crowd than before the VFL sold the Swans to him, the Swans were still buying a half page in the Tele just to get some attention. I see no credit's there.

    Character
    His tattoo removal business, "colourful" business associates and bankruptcies - his character raises more red flags than the National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party. Hell the AMA de-registered him, and they're renowned for looking after their own. All up a most insalubrious character.

    The last word
    The simple truth is that he was never really a Swans man. A Carlton member both before and after his brief period at the Swans. In his later years, he attested to this true allegiance and remarked that he only purchased the Swans because the blue bags weren't up for sale.
    Yes, he was a passionate Carlton supporter- but he was instrumental in putting us on the map in Sydney. Don’t underestimate how difficult it was/is to break into Rugby territory. With Tom Hafey and the great players he brought to us gave us a lot of joy, after 40 years in the doldrums. It needed a lot of showmanship which he delivered in droves and I for one relished the footy we played. Unfortunately it didn’t last, and we did fall in a heap.

    But thanks for the memories Geoffrey- you did your best for the Red and the White!

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO