Rd 5 vs West Coast @ Optus - Pre-Game Thread

[Goal Sneak]

Well. It's a change from "definitely". Personally, I prefer the generic "that's a really good question."

Agreed

[Ralph Dawg]

Completely agree, I would play Amartey ahead of McLean at this stage, though Hayden is a more reliable kick on goal.

All in all, I don’t think that’s a minority view here!

Amartey plays like a young Buddy at VFL level. Looks great and I think he seems to complement Logan nicely at that level. Plus he rucks well. I like McLean as a marking target and he's a good set shot but overall, Amartey seems to offer more.

[Goal Sneak]

Amartey plays like a young Buddy at VFL level. Looks great and I think he seems to complement Logan nicely at that level. Plus he rucks well. I like McLean as a marking target and he's a good set shot but overall, Amartey seems to offer more.

I really like the energy and mobility Amartey provides. McLean has a big tank and has been playing his role but with Buddy out, I'm not sure his game is as valuable.

[longmile]

I really like the energy and mobility Amartey provides. McLean has a big tank and has been playing his role but with Buddy out, I'm not sure his game is as valuable.

Which one is more valuable?

[Goal Sneak]

Which one is more valuable?

I'm saying with Buddy out, Amartey provides more

[longmile]

I'm saying with Buddy out, Amartey provides more

Agreed. McLean while a deadly set shot and a good pack mark, he's just too slow and one dimensional. Don't get me wrong, I like him, but I think Amartey has a bigger upside - and you're right, he plays more similarly too Buddy

[rb4x]

Kennedy the sub ????