Who gets your vote

[Plugger46]

Best/Favourite: Lockett

Worst: Aaron Rogers - in a photo finish with Paul Chambers.

Mark Hepburn for the other category. Reject from North and the Eagles who was genuinely ordinary.

[Chookbilly]

Best/Fav - Kelly, Goodes, Schwass, Eski

Disappointing - Ryan Fitzgerald (due only to injuries), McVeigh (so far, but still has time to change my mind), Josh Willoughby, Mark Powell, Mark Kinnear.

Wish they'd never worn the jumper - Ryan O'connor, Andrew Bomford, Nick Daffy, Paul Chambers, Stephen Tingay, Mark Eustice, and.... Bevo!

[goswannie14]

Favourites - Tony and Paul Morwood, Graham Teasdale, Gary Brice.

Worst - Paul Chambers

Player you wish hadn't worn red and white - The last 2 Geelong recruits (Chambers and what his name! )

[Chilcott]

Your not wrong Grim, though I wouldnt mind a few more Pies rejects as they seem to go Ok with us .Willo,Shaubs,Robbie Ahmat,MarkOrchard.
Couple of B/F winners in that lot mate.
Stick that up ya Eddie !!

You mention that Robbie Ahmat went OK.

IMO ordinary at best, much like his brother.

[Nico]

Best: John Roberts because he once kicked a goal after the siren at Geelong from a top mark in the square. Slowly went back from dead in front to prolong the agony for the ferals and slotted it, and the Swans crowd went nuts.

Worst: Jimmy West because he once missed a shot on a 45 degree angle from a metre out at Geelong, and the Swans crowd went nuts.

He also has the inglorious reputation of hitting the post to draw a match with Melbourne at the G and so started our run of 23 straight loses or thereabouts, IIRC.

[2005]

You mention that Robbie Ahmat went OK.

IMO ordinary at best, much like his brother.

Kicked 5 at the G one night against the Pies when were were struggling and we got up . That will do me. A memorable game,hostile,loud & we won.
Also kicked one of the all time run and bounce goals at The SCG against the Roos and we got up
Anything to jack off Collingwood supporters makes me happy.
Who is his brother ??

[Matt79]

Who is his brother ??

Sit-on

[Nico]

Sit-on

Who's his brother?

A. Rubber.

[Bart]

Kicked 5 at the G one night against the Pies when were were struggling and we got up . That will do me. A memorable game,hostile,loud & we won.
Also kicked one of the all time run and bounce goals at The SCG against the Roos and we got up
Anything to jack off Collingwood supporters makes me happy.
Who is his brother ??

for old times sake

YouTube - Robbie Ahmat vs Nth Melbourne

[swan_song]

Best players seen: Bobby Skilton/Greg Williams
Fav players: Paul Kelly/Plugger (can't split them)
Worst player seen: Ryan O'Connor, Bomford (Sheedy special stitch-up)
Most disappointed in: Barry Hall (2006 GF)
Most happy for: Barry Hall (2005 GF)
Like to hate most: Jude Bolton (cos he cant kick)
Most disappointing teams: 1987 (star studded duds); 97 (why didnt they have fire in their bellies after 96); 2007 (weak finals capitulation)
Most disappointing decision: Trading Schneiderpoo to the drunks...

[connolly]

[QUOTE=swan_song;361671]Best players seen: Bobby Skilton/Greg Williams
QUOTE]

Must say i only saw Skilton at the end of his career but he was a much better player than Williams. Could kick beautifully off either foot, strong inside, brilliant outside and couragous. Williams was more one dimensional and lacked pace. Very good player but not a great. Bobby Skilton was the greatest player to every play for the Bloods since the 60's. For what its worth the worst player (attitude and indiscipline outweighted his undoubted talent) was David Rhys-Jones. Saw him knock Garry Buckenara unconscious in an unprovoked cowardly punch on the edge of a pack at the SCG. I reckon Bucky paid us back in spades when he coached us. The other black mark against Rhys-Jones was that he deserted to Carlton. Unforgiveable

[goswannie14]

Must say i only saw Skilton at the end of his career but he was a much better player than Williams. Could kick beautifully off either foot, strong inside, brilliant outside and couragous. Williams was more one dimensional and lacked pace. Very good player but not a great. Bobby Skilton was the greatest player to every play for the Bloods since the 60's. For what its worth the worst player (attitude and indiscipline outweighted his undoubted talent) was David Rhys-Jones. Saw him knock Garry Buckenara unconscious in an unprovoked cowardly punch on the edge of a pack at the SCG. I reckon Bucky paid us back in spades when he coached us. The other black mark against Rhys-Jones was that he deserted to Carlton. Unforgiveable

Rhys-Jones was a thug, but he could also play. I remember his first touch in senior football. It was pouring with rain and a young Rhys-Jones in his senior debut at the lake Oval outran his opponent and produced a beautiful one handed pick up, then delivered the ball onto the chest of a team mate.