Rnd 21, vs Giants at Giants Stadium, on Saturday 5 August 7:30 PM

**Ludwig** · 1st August 2023, 10:20 PM

Originally Posted by MattW

I can see Fox conceding frees to Greene. Since round 11, Fox's personal free kick count is 0-8: https://afltables.com/afl/stats/play...Fox.html#20230.

Cunningham seems more likely to stay disciplined.

I don't see a solution to Greene. He's just too good. Fox is a better size matchup than Harry, and as I said earlier, Harry is probably slotted in to play Daniels, which looks a natural selection. I would imagine that a lot of Fox's frees against came because of height mismatches.

On another mattter, I saw an interview with Giant Jack Buckley. I didn't realise that he came from the Swans Academy and taken as a zone selection by GWS, like we did with Cunningham.

**Ludwig** · 1st August 2023, 10:31 PM

Originally Posted by Ruck'n'Roll

We've basically lost the centre clearance counts in most games this year, so playing McLean as first ruck could be seen as simply conceding that fact.
And although Ludwig does make a point regarding the capability of the Giants tall defence.
I hope we do actually play a ruckman this week, and ask McLean to focus on playing a completely negative game against Taylor, as he once did against Brisbane's Harris Andrews.

I think you will get your wish, even though I would disagree with it. I sense that Longmire wants to keep the 3 tall forward setup, and Hickey played well last week in the VFL.

I feel that if we go head to head with GWS and play a traditional setup, they wil be too strong for us. I think we should try to find something to make us hard to play against for their type of players.

**Ruck'n'Roll** · 2nd August 2023, 04:34 AM

Originally Posted by Ludwig

On another mattter, I saw an interview with Giant Jack Buckley. I didn't realise that he came from the Swans Academy and taken as a zone selection by GWS, like we did with Cunningham.

I read some time ago that Buckley didn't stay the course at the Swans academy, but bailed out at 15 or 16 because it was too intense.
Harry C didn't make the cut when the final GWS squad was named, we got him through the rookie draft.

**KTigers** · 2nd August 2023, 10:51 AM

Originally Posted by Ludwig

I don't see a solution to Greene. He's just too good. Fox is a better size matchup than Harry, and as I said earlier, Harry is probably slotted in to play Daniels, which looks a natural selection. I would imagine that a lot of Fox's frees against came because of height mismatches.

On another mattter, I saw an interview with Giant Jack Buckley. I didn't realise that he came from the Swans Academy and taken as a zone selection by GWS, like we did with Cunningham.

Buckley is having a great year. He and Sam Taylor have really been hard to get past lately. There is obviously a changing of
the guard there as even Haynes has been the sub of late. All the stars (Greene, Coniglio, Kelly and Whitfield) are in great form.
too. Coniglio in particular is almost in career best form. Maybe he's just playing footy now and not thinking about being
captain all the time.

**liz** · 2nd August 2023, 11:11 AM

The "In the Mix" column on the AFL site confirms that Green and Hogan are likely to be available for the Giant this week.

In the mix, R21: Who's under the pump, pushing for selection?