Alleged incident at hotel on Sunday night

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • UUaswan
    Senior Player
    • Sep 2024
    • 1445

    #496
    Originally posted by Merdo5555

    Total BS, there was no crime! They were punished to satisfy the baying mob!
    Cant be satisfied mate, now the narrative is " just because charges weren't laid doesnt mean there wasnt a crime" followed by some BS stat about conviction success.

    Boys forever tainted, the false accusations (im assuming here, due to no charges being laid) from the women who are never named or charged, Its never enough

    Imagine being presumed guilty for 3 months and then still presumed guilty even when your cleared

    Like with racism, everyone is a racist now and it has diminished the true meaning or a terrible racist POS.

    SA charge is just a casual claim nowadays but the affect on the falsely accused is still the same, they are forever tainted.

    How many scumbag politicians had their say, I doubt any will bother to correct the record.

    Comment

    • stevoswan
      Veterans List
      • Sep 2014
      • 8902

      #497
      Originally posted by Merdo5555

      Total BS, there was no crime! They were punished to satisfy the baying mob!
      Oh FFS.....if you can claim there was 'no crime', I'm @@@@ing glad you have nothing to do with the running of our club.

      There may have been no sexual assault and even that can't be totally proven but there was actions that are totally unacceptable in any decently run sporting organisation.

      That's the 'crime'. It's actually pathetic that you can't see that and keep blindly doubling down on your stupidity.

      Comment

      • mcs
        Travelling Swannie!!
        • Jul 2007
        • 8482

        #498
        @@@@ me I thought the crusades were over,,,,
        "You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."

        Comment

        • 0918330512
          Senior Player
          • Sep 2011
          • 1656

          #499
          The 4 players (excluding Bice) were not charged by Vic police because of insufficient evidence. That is actually quite different to being cleared, regardless of the headlines. That being said, there is nothing more to be said by the Vic police, from their perspective, it’s over. The civil case that persists is a fishing expedition by the “ladies” and their lawyers. Doesn’t cost them much to pursue this course of action in the hope they get something. The players know what they did or didn’t do, regardless of public outcomes, it’s their cross to bear (or not, if they know their innocence) and the divided public will likely maintain their opinions, regardless of the results. IMO it’s time to move on and let the players and club do what they are meant to do. Play football.

          Comment

          • Merdo5555
            Warming the Bench
            • Apr 2017
            • 289

            #500
            No whats pathetic and completely unacceptable is your inability to understand the choice wasnt between action and no action, there was a range of choices and the club took the path that had implicitly built into the fact there had been allegations of sexual misconduct and then claim in a PR statement it didnt.

            Again a 4 - 5 match suspension for drinking and bringing strippers back top hotel room was the fair correct punishment, of course it wasnt.

            But hey no problem the mob demanded more so they got it.

            Im surprised there isnt another Russel Brand red herring thrown away. By the way its nice to see, allegations made, investigations conducted, charges laid, trial held, convicted and jailed. I'm delighted to see the system working, a convicted rapist jailed, good news for all.

            Oh i see they actually did something but there is insufficient evidence, no they are presumed innocent until proven guilty. The ex-post facto attempts to justify the incredible overreaction to all are incredible to watch, the twist and turns are amusing.

            Whats pathetic is the morality police feeling the need to decide what is our isnt appropriate conduct in the privacy of someones hotel room. Pathetic, stick to your own bedroom.

            Drinking and bringing a woman/women back to your hotel room arent crimes dimwit. They are a breach of standards not worthy of 4+ match suspension, thats the point, thats always been the point. A suspension implicitly including a tariff for alleged criminal behaviour even though it was declined at the time. This is exactly why the punishment should have fit the actions rather than satisfy the angry mob. Its called justice, obviously to difficult a concept for you to accept in face of the mob. Better hope your never unfairly accused of something then you will understand why principle is so important.

            Comment

            • The Big Cat
              On the veteran's list
              • Apr 2006
              • 2417

              #501
              Originally posted by Merdo5555
              Whats pathetic is the morality police feeling the need to decide what is our isnt appropriate conduct in the privacy of someones hotel room. Pathetic, stick to your own bedroom.

              Drinking and bringing a woman/women back to your hotel room arent crimes dimwit. They are a breach of standards not worthy of 4+ match suspension, thats the point, thats always been the point.
              A couple of points.
              The players would have it in their contracts that they are not to bring the club (or the AFL) into disrepute. Regardless of any reasonable standard of morality, seven or more blokes drinking and perhaps consuming illicit drugs with “exotic dancers” at four in the morning more than fits the definition of disreputable. (The term “depraved” seems more appropriate).

              Secondly, the club was obliged under any reasonable organisational duty to act. If they had imposed a two week sanction and the team beat the Lions as happened, they would have the potential club-splitting decision of dropping five players from a side which had just beaten the reigning premiers to accommodate five selfish and juvenile teammates who I can only assume lack any moral compass in all senses of the term.
              Those who have the greatest power to hurt us are those we love.

              Comment

              • Merdo5555
                Warming the Bench
                • Apr 2017
                • 289

                #502
                Originally posted by The Big Cat

                A couple of points.
                The players would have it in their contracts that they are not to bring the club (or the AFL) into disrepute. Regardless of any reasonable standard of morality, seven or more blokes drinking and perhaps consuming illicit drugs with “exotic dancers” at four in the morning more than fits the definition of disreputable. (The term “depraved” seems more appropriate).

                Secondly, the club was obliged under any reasonable organisational duty to act. If they had imposed a two week sanction and the team beat the Lions as happened, they would have the potential club-splitting decision of dropping five players from a side which had just beaten the reigning premiers to accommodate five selfish and juvenile teammates who I can only assume lack any moral compass in all senses of the term.
                Club-splitting what a joke. Players come in and out due to suspension all the time, its unusual to have that many at once but so what, The players going out would be disappointed but realistic as you always pick the best team and they arent in it yet.

                Comment

                • stevoswan
                  Veterans List
                  • Sep 2014
                  • 8902

                  #503
                  Deleted.
                  Last edited by stevoswan; Yesterday, 08:45 PM.

                  Comment

                  • stevoswan
                    Veterans List
                    • Sep 2014
                    • 8902

                    #504
                    QUOTE=Merdo5555;n1259838]No whats pathetic and completely unacceptable is your inability to understand the choice wasnt between action and no action, there was a range of choices and the club took the path that had implicitly built into the fact there had been allegations of sexual misconduct and then claim in a PR statement it didnt.

                    Drinking and bringing a woman/women back to your hotel room arent crimes dimwit. They are a breach of standards not worthy of 4+ match suspension, thats the point, thats always been the point. A suspension implicitly including a tariff for alleged criminal behaviour even though it was declined at the time. This is exactly why the punishment should have fit the actions rather than satisfy the angry mob. Its called justice, obviously to difficult a concept for you to accept in face of the mob. Better hope your never unfairly accused of something then you will understand why principle is so important.[/QUOTE]

                    It's quite sad how over-confident you are that you can actually convince (with repeated and increasingly angry and exclamatory posts) those who disagree with you to see and accept your stance on all this.

                    Those who disagree with you believe the club when they said the suspension was for behavioural breaches outside of the sexual assault allegation....because the club actually has high standards, standards that you just can't agree with due to the fact you are on some faux tough but ultimately weak man anti 'woke' crusade that belongs in the 80's with the likes of Sam Newman.

                    Some of us have moved with the times.....it's time you did as well and just accept that you are wrong in your obsessive belief that the club cowered to a 'baying mob'. The 'baying mob' was actually the clubs own morals and standards, morals and standards that you would do well to catch up with. I can guarantee with confidence that your views make you an outlier among the fans of this club but I'm sure you'll wear this as a badge of pride. Misguided as that would be. If so, just try moving on with a modicum of dignity.

                    Comment

                    • lwjoyner
                      Senior Player
                      • Nov 2004
                      • 1223

                      #505
                      agree stevoswan, time to move

                      Comment

                      • Roadrunner
                        Senior Player
                        • Jan 2018
                        • 1614

                        #506
                        Let’s all move on from this Merdo! Forget what’s legal for a moment- say you’re the coach. These lads are drinking into the wee small hours of the morning, with finals around the corner. Of course a hefty punishment has to be handed out- it’s as simple as that, and nothing to do with a baying mob! Then to have allegations of possible SA, well that’s a separate matter and for professional footballers in their work environment it is potentially a sackable offence. It would only be legal in a private situation, not when they are at work and their hotel expenses are paid for by their employer.

                        Comment

                        Working...