Changes for Rnd 5 V West Coast

[bungwahl]

If anything it's McGlynn who deserves the McHack tag

[Triple B]

Nicknames have a habit of coming back into fashion quickly.

Unlike stadiums...

[RogueSwan]

McHack is hardly an appropriate nickname.
Macca has proved over the last 4-5 years that he has been a very good footballer and great leader of our club and deserves respect.
But if RWOer's want to use it ... so be it.

[barry]

McHack...still? Between ANZ and out of date nicknames, you're losing touch with 2016 Barry

Nicknames have a habit of coming back into fashion quickly.

[WauchopeAnalyst]

Wouldn't surprise me if Rampe got the job. Has played well on Riewoldt and Tex before, has the tank and pace and can burn him the other way. Teddy would be better as the loose tall I reckon.

Ted has stay home (back 50) and let Ramps run with Darling

[Melbourne_Blood]

Ted on Darling[emoji32][emoji32][emoji32]. At least he will get assistance in the back 50 but on the wing Im concerned [emoji54].

As a forward you dont have to be fast, smart is enough. Sam Mitchell, Diesel are/were total guns and I dont see Macca anymore in the class of Heppell or Pendlebury as a distributor.

Macca a permanent flanker/pocket and a little time in Mids gives us 25-30 goals in a season.

Wouldn't surprise me if Rampe got the job. Has played well on Riewoldt and Tex before, has the tank and pace and can burn him the other way. Teddy would be better as the loose tall I reckon.

[Mug Punter]

We have plenty of speed and skill in our young mid/forward players.

Hannebery 25
Parker 23
Mitchell 22
Cunningham 22
Lloyd 22
Robinson 21
Jones 21
Hewett 21
Rose 20
Heeney 19
Mills 19
Papley 19

Plenty to work with. ???

We've got a good young list and I'm happy with the changes for Saturday

[WauchopeAnalyst]

We have plenty of speed and skill in our young mid/forward players.

Hannebery 25
Parker 23
Mitchell 22
Cunningham 22
Lloyd 22
Robinson 21
Jones 21
Hewett 21
Rose 20
Heeney 19
Mills 19
Papley 19

Plenty to work with. ???

[WauchopeAnalyst]

Ted on Darling????????????. At least he will get assistance in the back 50 but on the wing Im concerned ????.

As a forward you dont have to be fast, smart is enough. Sam Mitchell, Diesel are/were total guns and I dont see Macca anymore in the class of Heppell or Pendlebury as a distributor.

Macca a permanent flanker/pocket and a little time in Mids gives us 25-30 goals in a season.

[CureTheSane]

No surprises in the changes for me. The club was never going to play 3 ruckmen, nor should they unless Tippo was FF for the game

McVeigh frustrated the hell out of me last year, which is why I've been critical this year.
Gave him a pass in his game back (should not have walked into the side)
I'll be watching him again.
Hope he proves me wrong, but he seems a step down, especially this year.

[frankee]

Teddy to remind everyone why he is still playing in this one.

[ugg]

Emg Jones Nankervis Rose

[707]

In George and Sinkers
Out Nanka and Deano

No surprises there. George only had the one poor game and bounced back last week in the NEAFL so logical to replace the disappointing Towers.

Reckon Rose will be ruing his down game last week after tearing it up the previous few weeks. Glad they are rewarding good NEAFL form, puts everyone on notice both seniors without established form and NEAFL players to keep up good performances. Have a good one George and show them what they're missing Sinclair.

An unfortunate in is number 23 umpire Robert Findlayson, can be relied on to burn you with a few poor decisions.

[ugg]

In George and Sinkers
Out Nanka and Deano

[Ludwig]

Mchack is slow. In a team that's slow. In a backline that is slower. We cannot afford to play mitchell and mchack in the same team. 1 slow small man you can live with .two and you can ?iss a flag goodbye.
Mitchell is more value to the team than mchack.

You mean like, for example, Sam Mitchell and Luke Hodge?

And it's amazing how rarely McVeigh gets tackled, considering how 'slow' he is.