Rd 23 v St Kilda @ Marvel

[liz]

Yeah, forgot about Hanners!

[MattW]

I'd have him (Rowbottom) as BSwOG against the Saints but Max King, Jack Steele, Jack Sinclair and maybe Ben Long all have claims to votes from the game. Long's stats are impressive, but he was also one of the worst offenders of the Saints messing around with uncontested marks that went precisely nowhere during the third quarter at a time when Saints were largely on top and would probably have won had they been more decisive in that quarter.

I reckon the Saints will get a larger share of the votes from that game than the Swans. We won because we created and took more dangerous moments.

My votes ????

5 - Rowbottom
4 - Sinclair
3 - Hannebery
2 - Heeney
1 - Hayward

The Saints had more very impressive players and no other Swans came near it.

But those three Swans pulled their team over the line, which inflates their value.

[TheBloods]

Interestingly Kane Cornes thinks Hayward could be a top 20 player in the comp next year


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hes a dill , but Hayward is good

[liz]

Interestingly Kane Cornes thinks Hayward could be a top 20 player in the comp next year


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Playing for Adelaide?

[gloveski]

i wanted to talk about the game but no .

You know who Hayward reminds me of , Kelvin Templeton . Used to be a CHF but was closer to Haywards size than a modern fwd . Great leap and speed , got across the ground well . Barely went a game without kicking at least a couple . That is Haywards role in this team . He wont be a star , he doesnt get enough of the ball or get enough goals , but if he takes his marks and kicks his goals , he will be great to have in the team . Just dont trust that he will keep it up or wont go missing in finals . Suppose have to wait and see

Interestingly Kane Cornes thinks Hayward could be a top 20 player in the comp next year


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[liz]

Probably BOG against the Saints.

I'd have him (Rowbottom) as BSwOG against the Saints but Max King, Jack Steele, Jack Sinclair and maybe Ben Long all have claims to votes from the game. Long's stats are impressive, but he was also one of the worst offenders of the Saints messing around with uncontested marks that went precisely nowhere during the third quarter at a time when Saints were largely on top and would probably have won had they been more decisive in that quarter.

I reckon the Saints will get a larger share of the votes from that game than the Swans. We won because we created and took more dangerous moments.

[Faunac8]

TheBloods, I am one who protests against posters baiting you.

But if you are going to suggest we bring in Gus and Roberts, and you want us to give it serious consideration, you also need to state who they will replace (and you can’t include Rowbottom as he has clearly been excellent in recent weeks).

So if Roberts and Gus come in, where will they play and who gets dropped or moved into another position other than Rowbottom?

So Roberts in for Clarke? Gus in for McInerney and Mills or Gulden to play more on the wing and in defence?

Not baiting just my opinion but I would be surprised if James hasn’t picked up at least 12 out of 20 coaches votes in the last two weeks
Probably BOG against the Saints.

[Maltopia]

TheBloods, I am one who protests against posters baiting you.

But if you are going to suggest we bring in Gus and Roberts, and you want us to give it serious consideration, you also need to state who they will replace (and you can’t include Rowbottom as he has clearly been excellent in recent weeks).

So if Roberts and Gus come in, where will they play and who gets dropped or moved into another position other than Rowbottom?

So Roberts in for Clarke? Gus in for McInerney and Mills or Gulden to play more on the wing and in defence?

[TheBloods]

Templeton was 2 inches taller at time when most ruckmen were about 6'5". He was a tall KPF in his time. Hayward is a very different kind of player.

i am not saying they are the same role i am saying they play the same . i liked Templeton's leap and had good speed and did the same things around the ground .

[Auntie.Gerald]

I must say Hayward always reminded me of one of his states best.......Brett Burton

Similar height and late leap....and quirky running style and unique marks

[Bloods05]

i wanted to talk about the game but no .

You know who Hayward reminds me of , Kelvin Templeton . Used to be a CHF but was closer to Haywards size than a modern fwd . Great leap and speed , got across the ground well . Barely went a game without kicking at least a couple . That is Haywards role in this team . He wont be a star , he doesnt get enough of the ball or get enough goals , but if he takes his marks and kicks his goals , he will be great to have in the team . Just dont trust that he will keep it up or wont go missing in finals . Suppose have to wait and see

Templeton was 2 inches taller at time when most ruckmen were about 6'5". He was a tall KPF in his time. Hayward is a very different kind of player.

[TheBloods]

Please make the job for Liz and any other moderator a little easier.

Let's be alot more considerate of their time and things they could be doing other than watching the kids in the sand pit.

I can't believe this garbage is still going o re bating TB.

It is mind blowing.

i wanted to talk about the game but no .

You know who Hayward reminds me of , Kelvin Templeton . Used to be a CHF but was closer to Haywards size than a modern fwd . Great leap and speed , got across the ground well . Barely went a game without kicking at least a couple . That is Haywards role in this team . He wont be a star , he doesnt get enough of the ball or get enough goals , but if he takes his marks and kicks his goals , he will be great to have in the team . Just dont trust that he will keep it up or wont go missing in finals . Suppose have to wait and see

[Auntie.Gerald]

Please make the job for Liz and any other moderator a little easier.

Let's be alot more considerate of their time and things they could be doing other than watching the kids in the sand pit.

I can't believe this garbage is still going o re bating TB.

It is mind blowing.

[AB Swannie]

Get Roberts and Gus in !

Wrong. God help us.

[aardvark]

I hope Hickey improves before Friday week or we're going to get hammered at the clearances.