Foote would be better than Hanners or KJ or Robbo or Dawson or Towers and probably more. Pains me to say it but there has been more than enough evidence to say they should be dropped.Originally Posted by 707
Foote would be better than Hanners or KJ or Robbo or Dawson or Towers and probably more. Pains me to say it but there has been more than enough evidence to say they should be dropped.
Newman's gone into the senior side three times this season and looked horrible every time.
Newman looked pretty good last year. Feels like the way he's been "managed" this year has undermined his confidence. He can't be any slower than Hanners, and he has to be a better ball user. Every single midfielder in the AFL is a better kick of the ball than Hanners.
They've used him in unusual ways and dropped him straight away. He has to be better value than KJ or Hanners just on statistics.
If we don't bite the bullet we're cactus this year. Maybe a loss to Geelong and the three passengers again not making a contribution might make them change personnel, winning covers the cracks but on RWO we can see them!
Mr. Pink has returned. Interestingly, Darcy Cordell who played for us as a topup earlier this year, will be lining up for the Giants.
NEAFL Round 14
Saturday, July 7, 2018
Sydney Swans (3rd) v GIANTS (5th) at North Dalton Park, 12pm
*This match will be streamed live on NEAFL TV (youtube.com/northeastafl)
*Live Champion Data statistics available on the Official NEAFL App
SYDNEY
B: 6. Jordan Foote 21. Jack Maibaum 2. Alex Johnson
HB: 34. Jordan Dawson 31. Harrison Marsh 47. Toby Pink
C: 41. Jake Brown 52. Harrison Parker 51. Connor Flanagan
HF: 20. Sam Reid 28. Nic Newman 50. Sam Wicks
F: 55. Bailey Stewart 46. Joel Amartey 58. Mitchell Rogers
Foll: 17. Darcy Cameron 38. Colin O’Riordan 32. James Bell
Inter: 53. Max Ries 49. Isaac Bartholomaeus 56. Dylan Smith 57. Kyle Veerhuis48. Sam Thorne
In: 53. Max Ries 49. Isaac Bartholomaeus 56. Dylan Smith 57. Kyle Veerhuis 48. Sam Thorne 47. Toby Pink 52. Harrison Parker
Out: 43. Lewis Melican (injured) 33. Ryley Stoddart (injured) 45. Angus Styles (injured) 53. Dominic Soffe (omitted) 49. Mark Kannan (omitted) 52. Josh Rayner (omitted) 48. Luke Parks (omitted)
New: 53. Max Ries 48. Sam Thorne
GIANTS
B: 50. Tyh Evans 39. Tim Mohr 29. Matt Wilson
HB: 48. Max Beaumont 42. Jake Stein 13. Isaac Cumming
C: 54. Riley Budd 51. Riley Corbett 52. James Peatling
HF: 45. Jack Rowston 43. Darcy Cordell 11. Ed Perryman
F: 53. Will Clark 28. Zach Sproule 47. Tom Banuelos
Foll: 30. Matthew Flynn 46. Rhys Pollock 21. Matthew Buntine
Inter (from): 16. Brent Daniels 36. Harry Perryman 40. Adam Kennedy 34. Nick Shipley 10. Aiden Bonar 25. Lachlan Keeffe 14. Tim Taranto 19. Nick Haynes
Emer: 41. Jai Reed 49. Shaun Driscoll
In: 29. Matt Wilson 51. Riley Corbett 48. Max Beaumont 43. Darcy Cordell 47. Tom Banuelos 14. Tim Taranto 19. Nick Haynes 11. Ed Perryman
Out: 41. Matthew McGrory (omitted) 51. Liam Delahunty (omitted) 49. Lachlan Tanner (omitted) 43. Dylan Buckley (injured)
New: 29. Matt Wilson 43. Darcy Cordell
The match is at North Dalton Park, Wollongong. Will be live streamed:
Wow Toby Pink is still at the club.... one might have wondered
Looking forward to sitting down and watching the live stream on this one, should be a good game hopefully!
"You get the feeling that like Monty Python's Black Knight, the Swans would regard amputation as merely a flesh wound."
NEAFL 2018 Round 14
Sydney Swans Reserves v Giants @ North Dalton Park, Wollongong
Saturday 7th July 2018
12:00pm
North Dalton Park
This will be the 2nd match at North Dalton Oval for the Swans, having played Ainslie in Round 14 2014 and winning that game by 6 points.
After losing the first 4 games of the season, the Swans's fortunes have turned completely around. With important players returning from injury adding strength to the side, they have reeled off 7 straight wins and are now within striking distance of joint leaders Southport and Sydney Uni. However with a tough run home - 5 of the last 7 games are against opposition AFL teams as well as the always difficult road trip to the Northern Territory - the Reserves will be out to seal victory against an undermanned Giants team to consolidate their position in the Top 6. And on an individual level, there are spots up for grabs in the senior team following the injuries that occurred during last night's loss.
The Swans have named 13 listed players and with the AFL match out of the way, all 4 emergencies should line up for us. The Giants meanwhile don't have that luxury with their away game in Perth, meaning they will be down to 8-9 listed players. However they have shown in the last 4 weeks, they can manage to win despite being down on experienced AFL players.
NEAFL Ladder
Position Team Played Wins Losses Draws FF For Against Percentage Points 1 Southport 11 8 3 0 0 1117 798 139.97% 32 2 Sydney University 11 8 3 0 0 888 876 101.37% 32 3 Sydney 11 7 4 0 0 889 649 136.98% 28 4 Canberra 11 7 4 0 0 966 784 123.21% 28 5 Giants 11 6 5 0 0 909 944 96.29% 24 6 Aspley 12 6 6 0 0 911 962 94.70% 24 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7 Brisbane 11 5 6 0 0 993 767 129.47% 20 8 Gold Coast 12 5 7 0 0 748 987 75.79% 20 9 NT Thunder 11 3 8 0 0 891 1186 75.13% 12 10 Redland 11 1 10 0 0 784 1143 68.59% 4
Recent Form
Reserves
Round Team Venue Result F A R1 Giants Home Loss 69 73 R2 Brisbane Lions Away Loss 74 124 R3 BYE BYE BYE BYE BYE R4 Gold Coast Suns Away Loss 49 58 R5 Aspley Home Loss 71 72 R6 Giants Away Win 73 42 R7 Southport Home Win 131 43 R8 Brisbane Lions Away Win 70 54 R9 Sydney Uni Away Win 98 47 R10 Redland Away Win 67 45 R11 Gold Coast Suns Away Win 107 40 R12 BYE BYE BYE BYE BYE R13 Brisbane Lions Home Win 80 51
Giants
Round Team Venue Result F A R1 Sydney Swans Away Win 73 69 R2 Gold Coast Suns Away Loss 72 93 R3 BYE BYE BYE BYE BYE R4 Brisbane Lions Home Loss 40 133 R5 Southport Away Loss 47 133 R6 Sydney Swans Home Loss 42 73 R7 Canberra Away Loss 74 125 R8 Redland Home Win 124 59 R9 NT Thunder Away Win 96 45 R10 Gold Coast Suns Home Win 95 43 R11 BYE BYE BYE BYE BYE R12 Brisbane Lions Away Win 146 111 R13 Aspley Home Win 100 60
Head-to-Head
Swans Reserves 16
Giants 12
It's 1-1 split in 2018 after the Swans claimed all 3 games last season.
Past Meetings
2018
Round 1 @ Sydney Cricket Ground
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Reserves 1.4 4.8 7.12 9.15 69 Giants 2.1 7.4 9.5 11.7 73
Type Players Goals J.Amartey 2, J.Rose 2, J.Bell, J.Foote, B.Stewart, D.Robinson, I.Bartholomaeus Best H.Marsh, D.Robinson, D.Smith, J.Maibaum, B.Ronke
Round 6 @ Spotless Stadium
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Giants 0.5 1.6 3.8 5.12 42 Reserves 1.2 5.5 8.8 10.13 73
Type Players Goals A.Tipungwuti 3, H.Marsh 2, D.Cameron 2, M.Ling, C.O'Riordan, J.Webster Best H.Marsh, N.Newman, A.Aliir, C.O'Riordan, D.Cameron, J.Brown
2017
Round 4 @ Sydney Cricket Ground
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Reserves 5.2 9.7 11.8 13.13 91 Giants 2.1 4.2 8.6 8.7 55
Type Players Goals J.Rose 4, J.Dawson 2, T.Pink 2, S.Murray, S.Fisher, S.Edwards, L.Robertson, D.Cameron Best S.Murray, M.Talia, J.Laidler, B.Jack, J.Dawson
Round 11 @ Blacktown International Sports Park
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Reserves 6.1 10.6 18.15 28.17 185 Giants 0 0 1.0 2.2 14
Type Players Goals J.Dawson 4, S.Fisher 4, S.Wicks 4, S.Edwards 3, K.Tippett 3, O.Florent 2, G.Rohan 2, B.Ronke 2, J.Foote, H.Carr, J.Laidler, B.Jack Best J.Laidler, O.Florent, J.Dawson, B.Jack, S.Fisher, K.Tippett
Round 16 @ Spotless Stadium
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Giants 2.2 5.3 7.3 8.5 53 Reserves 4.3 7.7 12.9 16.16 112
Type Players Goals J.Dawson 4, J.Rose 3, A.Aliir 2, W.Hayward 2, J.Deep, S.Fisher, T.Pink, S.Wicks, H.Marsh Best C.Sinclair, A.Aliir, J.Laidler, C.O'Riordan, J.Rose, H.Marsh
Last game
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Reserves 2.0 7.2 11.5 12.8 80 Brisbane Lions 2.3 3.5 5.6 7.9 51
Type Players Goals J.Dawson 3, J.Bell 2, S.Reid 2, N.Newman, S.Wicks, A.Johnson, H.Marsh, M.Kannan Best H.Marsh, J.Dawson, C.O'Riordan, D.Cameron, N.Newman, C.Flanagan
Team Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Final Giants 3.4 6.7 11.9 15.10 100 Aspley 4.1 5.7 7.7 8.12 60
Type Players Goals D.Buckley 3, Z.Sproule 3, N.Shipley 3, M.McGrory 2, J.Rowston 2, L.Delahunty, R.Pollock Best M.Flynn, M.Buntine, N.Shipley, A.Kennedy, A.Bonar, J.Rowston
Team List
Listed players
# Name Games Goals Best Votes MVP votes Notes 2 Alex JOHNSON 4 1 0 0 6 Jordan FOOTE 3 1 0 0 17 Darcy CAMERON 11 15 36 37 Senior emergency 20 Sam REID 1 2 0 0 21 Jack MAIBAUM 11 0 11 0 28 Nic NEWMAN 8 5 31 40 Senior emergency 31 Harrison MARSH 5 3 25 19 Senior emergency 32 James BELL 3 3 0 0 34 Jordan DAWSON 3 4 5 5 38 Colin O'RIORDAN 10 2 22 19 Senior emergency 41 Jake BROWN 8 2 6 1 46 Joel AMARTEY 11 12 0 0 47 Toby PINK 0 0 0 0
Changes
In: Pink
Out: Lewis MELICAN (injured), Ryley STODDART (injured), Angus STYLES (injured)
Pink finally makes his long awaited return. Will be play back or forward? Perhaps even a stint in the ruck?
Stoddart and Styles were injured early last week and Melican was on limited game time so there shouldn't be too many structural changes from last week's win again the Lions. Kennelly said that Bell ran out of puff due to playing more minutes than expected due to the injury, and ended up in a back pocket.
Foote, Dawson, Brown, Newman, Bell forms a solid midfield unit with Marsh and O'Riordan as other options if required. Cameron and Amartey have been the regular ruck pairing, and with Reid and Pink provide height in the Swans' forwardline.
Academy Players/Topups
# Name Games Goals Best Votes MVP votes Notes 48 Sam THORNE 0 0 0 0 NEAFL debut 49 Isaac BARTHOLOMAEUS 3 1 0 0 50 Sam WICKS 6 2 0 0 51 Connor FLANAGAN 5 0 1 0 52 Harrison PARKER 1 0 2 0 53 Max RIES 0 0 0 0 NEAFL debut 55 Bailey STEWART 9 8 6 9 56 Dylan SMITH 6 0 4 0 57 Kyle VEERHUIS 2 0 0 0 58 Mitchell ROGERS 8 1 0 0
In: Bartholomaeus, Parker, Ries, Smith, Thorne, Veerhuis
Out: Mark KANNAN, Luke PARKS, Josh RAYNER, Dominic SOFFE
Flanagan was impressive last week and was named as one of our best six players. Wicks and Stewart have impressed over the course of the season as half-forwards.
Statistics
Kicks
Player Games Avg. Kicks Nic NEWMAN 8 22.6 Harrison MARSH 5 20.8 Dan ROBINSON 6 20.0 Colin O'RIODAN 10 15.7 Robbie FOX 5 14.8
Handballs
Player Games Avg. Handballs Daniel ROBINSON 6 15.8 Dean TOWERS 4 12.5 Colin O'RIORDAN 10 12.0 Robbie FOX 5 11.2 Nic NEWMAN 8 9.5
Disposals
Player Games Avg. Disposals Daniel ROBINSON 6 35.8 Nic NEWMAN 8 32.1 Harrison MARSH 5 28.2 Colin O'RIORDAN 10 27.7 Robbie FOX 5 26.0
Marks
Player Games Avg. Marks Colin O'RIORDAN 10 8.3 Darcy CAMERON 11 8.1 Daniel ROBINSON 6 7.2 Nic NEWMAN 8 6.5 Aliir ALIIR 8 4.9
Tackles
Player Games Avg. Tackles Ben RONKE 2 9.0 Harry PARKER 1 7.0 Nic NEWMAN 8 6.9 Daniel ROBINSON 6 6.0 Robbie FOX 5 5.6
Hitouts
Player Games Avg. Hitouts Darcy CAMERON 11 33.7 Joel AMARTEY 11 6.2 Aliir ALIIR 8 3.0 Zac CAMERON 2 2.0 Dean TOWERS 4 1.3
Clearances
Player Games Avg. Clearances Daniel ROBINSON 6 9.5 Robbie FOX 5 5.2 Nic NEWMAN 8 5.1 Dean TOWERS 4 5.0 Darcy CAMERON 11 4.1
Inside 50s
Player Games Avg. Inside 50s Daniel ROBINSON 6 6.7 Nic NEWMAN 8 5.8 Harrison MARSH 5 5.2 Dean TOWERS 4 5.0 Ben RONKE 2 5.0 Adam TIPUNGWUTI 2 7.0 Hamish ELLEM 1 5.0
Rebound 50s
Player Games Avg. Rebound 50s Harrison MARSH 5 6.0 Colin O'RIORDAN 10 4.7 Nic NEWMAN 8 4.3 Alex JOHNSON 4 3.0 Lewis MELICAN 1 3.0 James WEBSTER 1 3.0
Goals
Player Games Total Goals James ROSE 8 16 Darcy CAMERON 11 15 Joel AMARTEY 11 12 Josh STERN 4 8 Bailey STEWART 9 8
Best Votes
Player Games Total Votes Darcy CAMERON 11 37 Nic NEWMAN 8 31 Daniel ROBINSON 6 26 Harrison MARSH 5 25 Colin O'RIORDAN 10 22
NEAFL MVP Votes
Player Games Total Votes Daniel ROBINSON 6 41 Nic NEWMAN 8 40 Darcy CAMERON 11 37 Harrison MARSH 5 19 Colin O'RIORDAN 10 19
Giants (listed players in bold)
B: 50. Tyh EVANS 39. Tim MOHR 29. Matt WILSON HB: 48. Max BEAUMONT 42. Jake STEIN 13. Isaac CUMMING C: 54. Riley BUDD 51. Riley CORBETT 52. James PEATLING HF: 45. Jack ROWSTON 43. Darcy CORDELL 11. Ed PERRYMAN F: 53. Will CLARK 28. Zach SPROULE 47. Tom BANUELOS Foll: 30. Matthew FLYNN 46. Rhys POLLOCK 21. Matthew BUNTINE Int (from): 16. Brent DANIELS 36. Harry PERRYMAN 40. Adam KENNEDY 34. Nick SHIPLEY 10. Aiden BONAR 25. Lachlan KEEFFE 14. Tim TARANTO 19. Nick HAYNES Emg: 41. Jai REED 49. Shaun DRISCOLL 55. Nathan COXALL
In: WBanuelos, Beaumont, Corbett, Cordell, Haynes, E.Perryman, Taranto, Wilson
Out: Dylan BUCKLEY (injured), Liam DELAHUNTY (omitted), Matthew McGRORY (omitted), Lachlan TANNER (omitted)
At least 4 and maybe up to 6 of the extended bench will be on AFL duty, either playing or as travelling emergency. Taranto and Haynes are certainties to be in that group. Keeffe likely to replace the injured Patton as a tall forward/ruck, and the other 5 all have claims to be given a spot as they have all been playing well in the NEAFL. Whoever is left behind will form the nucleus of their on-ball division.
Of the Giants named on field, Sproule has had some great matchups with Harry Marsh, but with a lack of another tall forward, Maibaum may be the man for him this time. Buntine's usual position is as a third tall defender but has been used in the midfield when the Giants have been short of numbers. Mohr is the most experienced defender and hence a logical choice to mark Reid but Sam's propensity to roam further upfield may see Cumming assigned the task instead.
While Flynn will be filling in for regular number 1 ruck Dawson Simpson, he showed last week he is no slouch in the rucking department, tallying 13 hitouts to advantage against former Melbourne Demon Jake Spencer. One of his strengths is his mobility which will pose an interesting challenge for the in-form Darcy Cameron.
Thanks Ugg, great write up as usual. Looking forward to the game updates.
With half the senior side injured last night there are places up for grabs so I expect those players will be really switched on tomorrow.
Great to finally see Pink after seeing Red yesterday. Swans should win this as Giants are shorthanded and it should be much more enjoyable than last nights garbage.
Daniels Perryman Shipley Taranto Haynes omitted from their extended bench.
9 vs 13 then, in our favour albeit some listed players coming back from injury
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks