2026 List Management

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • crackedactor 01
    replied
    I thought it was good to hear Heeney and Warner will be going nowhere and even Blakey is only 50/50 chance. This Pulman five were silly but there is no evidence that their are sexual monsters.

    Leave a comment:


  • Roadrunner
    replied
    Originally posted by imuninformedtwo

    If I was Joel, I’d take the money. I saw something the other day that puts his injury record in perspective. We love Sam Reid to bits, but he was heavily injury prone at times. Joel is more than halfway through his career and has played less than half the games Reid played in his career, and he’d have to play full five seasons to get near his career games total. Joel’s getting paid on potential and crossed fingers by Carlton. Our offer was based on actual production.
    Agreed- Carlton need him more than we do, and due to his injury record if our offer was fairly close to Carlton’s then it was a bit generous!

    Still, he can be a very good impact player and so I’m sorry to lose him, especially to Carlton!

    Leave a comment:


  • imuninformedtwo
    replied
    Originally posted by Roadrunner
    I’m a bit sad we are losing Joel. He can be very good but also inconsistent and has been injury prone. His early years were promising and we gave him many opportunities to improve during that time. It’s somewhat disappointing that now that he has matured, he’s become a free agent and so he’s chasing the big bucks. I understand money talks but is this fair to the club that nursed him? Ok, we’ll receive a compo pick, but that’s not the point. I can accept if a player wants to move for a genuine reason like lack of opportunities but not just for the money, unless the gap is really significant, which may not be the case here it now seems.

    Yes, we got Charlie from Carlton. But he wanted out for his own good reasons and was willing to take a pay cut! He’s certainly no mercenary!
    If I was Joel, I’d take the money. I saw something the other day that puts his injury record in perspective. We love Sam Reid to bits, but he was heavily injury prone at times. Joel is more than halfway through his career and has played less than half the games Reid played in his career, and he’d have to play full five seasons to get near his career games total. Joel’s getting paid on potential and crossed fingers by Carlton. Our offer was based on actual production.

    Leave a comment:


  • Roadrunner
    replied
    I’m a bit sad we are losing Joel. He can be very good but also inconsistent and has been injury prone. His early years were promising and we gave him many opportunities to improve during that time. It’s somewhat disappointing that now that he has matured, he’s become a free agent and so he’s chasing the big bucks. I understand money talks but is this fair to the club that nursed him? Ok, we’ll receive a compo pick, but that’s not the point. I can accept if a player wants to move for a genuine reason like lack of opportunities but not just for the money, unless the gap is really significant, which may not be the case here it now seems.

    Yes, we got Charlie from Carlton. But he wanted out for his own good reasons and was willing to take a pay cut! He’s certainly no mercenary!

    Leave a comment:


  • stevoswan
    replied
    Originally posted by UUaswan

    Maybe

    Massive disappointment but its done now, move on.

    As a player, how could you still hold anything against Warner and Heeney

    Move on, the longer this goes the more bull@@@@ it is
    It's actually becoming exhausting....you now telling others to "move on". Just wow.

    Leave a comment:

Working...