2026 List Management

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Dow
    replied
    Originally posted by UUaswan

    I think our issue is when Blakey and Rampe have been regarded as a tall defenders.

    Neither are, we are much better with Tom, Will and Lewis/Hamling with Wicks as the small and others attacking

    Blakey is Jordan Dawson V2, a waste down back
    Melican maybe classed as a tall defender but he certainly doesn't play like one

    Leave a comment:


  • lwjoyner
    replied
    screwed bt the afl once again. itesting to see wharlions get for neale. note gws gets 26 gor greene a lot older with a bigger salary.

    Leave a comment:


  • cubby
    replied
    Band 3 (pick 40+) compo for a 27 year old with a 5 year $700k+ contract...That is lousy to say the least.
    Had to be a band 2 to any fair minded person, which would still only be a pick in the early 20s.

    Leave a comment:


  • UUaswan
    replied
    Originally posted by crackedactor 01

    Just wondering when the de-listing will start? Adams and Amartey and maybe Rampe gone. Will players like Hamling, Ladhams and Melican hold their positions?
    Melican has to, Ladhams will if there is no other interest.

    Band 3 for Amartey, be in the 40s by the time we get it

    Leave a comment:


  • crackedactor 01
    replied
    Originally posted by UUaswan

    I think our issue is when Blakey and Rampe have been regarded as a tall defenders.

    Neither are, we are much better with Tom, Will and Lewis/Hamling with Wicks as the small and others attacking

    Blakey is Jordan Dawson V2, a waste down back
    Just wondering when the de-listing will start? Adams and Amartey and maybe Rampe gone. Will players like Hamling, Ladhams and Melican hold their positions?

    Leave a comment:


  • UUaswan
    replied
    Originally posted by BRS328

    A lot will be answered in the coming weeks. As you say a lot will depend on whether Rampe goes around again and like for like you would think Snell would the replacement. This will be his fourth season so he needs to stand up now.
    The other key decisions are the future of Cunningham and Hamling. Both are well regarded within, and despite some negative comments on Hamling on this site, his form in the later part of the season was very good.
    The 3 tall’s on the backline, McCartin, Edwards and Blakey, in my opinion are the obvious starters with backup support from Melican, Hamling etc, but realistically Andrew is still at least a year away from being a regular starter.
    One last point, statistically the Swans defence was rated in the top three over the season, and just as importantly stood up when it counted in both finals.
    I think our issue is when Blakey and Rampe have been regarded as a tall defenders.

    Neither are, we are much better with Tom, Will and Lewis/Hamling with Wicks as the small and others attacking

    Blakey is Jordan Dawson V2, a waste down back

    Leave a comment:


  • BRS328
    replied
    Originally posted by Roadrunner

    With Millsey out and Ramps future uncertain- he will be managed even if he can play one more year, I’m sure three youngsters will be given opportunities in the backline. We definitely need at least one tall but preferably two, so I’m thinking Snell and Riak, though we may pick up a trade if a good defender becomes available.

    A lot will be answered in the coming weeks. As you say a lot will depend on whether Rampe goes around again and like for like you would think Snell would the replacement. This will be his fourth season so he needs to stand up now.
    The other key decisions are the future of Cunningham and Hamling. Both are well regarded within, and despite some negative comments on Hamling on this site, his form in the later part of the season was very good.
    The 3 tall’s on the backline, McCartin, Edwards and Blakey, in my opinion are the obvious starters with backup support from Melican, Hamling etc, but realistically Andrew is still at least a year away from being a regular starter.
    One last point, statistically the Swans defence was rated in the top three over the season, and just as importantly stood up when it counted in both finals.

    Leave a comment:


  • Roadrunner
    replied
    Originally posted by lwjoyner
    interesting that patrick snell voted best vfl plaer of the year and with bowman's injury concerns shoyld get a game next year perhaps on half back line. they both should have been given an opportunity in 2026 just to see how thet would go in the big league.
    With Millsey out and Ramps future uncertain- he will be managed even if he can play one more year, I’m sure three youngsters will be given opportunities in the backline. We definitely need at least one tall but preferably two, so I’m thinking Snell and Riak, though we may pick up a trade if a good defender becomes available.


    Leave a comment:


  • lwjoyner
    replied
    interesting that patrick snell voted best vfl plaer of the year and with bowman's injury concerns shoyld get a game next year perhaps on half back line. they both should have been given an opportunity in 2026 just to see how thet would go in the big league.

    Leave a comment:


  • KSAS
    replied
    Originally posted by imuninformedtwo

    Don’t want him. He’s fallen away. Rather give Snell his shot, or if he keeps improving, Bowman.
    Hoping also Riak Andrews gets to play a full season and puts his hands up for selection. Hope he does a Will Edwards in that regard.

    Leave a comment:


  • Roadrunner
    replied
    Originally posted by imuninformedtwo

    Don’t want him. He’s fallen away. Rather give Snell his shot, or if he keeps improving, Bowman.
    Yes, let’s develop our young players- that’s the best way going forward. Of course if an experienced player becomes available and wants to join us, by all means but not at the expense of preventing a promising young talent from getting a spot. It has worked to some extent with Hamling but we have to build for the future. The Lions are the model to follow!

    Leave a comment:


  • imuninformedtwo
    replied
    Originally posted by BRS328

    I was under the impression that Himmelberg has already recommitted to GWS. Correct me if I am wrong
    Don’t want him. He’s fallen away. Rather give Snell his shot, or if he keeps improving, Bowman.

    Leave a comment:


  • KSAS
    replied
    Originally posted by Velour&Ruffles

    I agree with your assessment of the deficiencies of this - clearly not done by a Swans fan (or close observer). Also, where the heck is Cunningham?
    Oh yes, Cunningham is another another omission i'd missed. Good pick up V&R and lazy oversight by the HS!

    Leave a comment:


  • KSAS
    replied
    Originally posted by stevoswan

    After he knocked back Tassie then North saying he was very happy in Sydney with a new business venture? Wow.....quite strange and a little disappointing.

    Also, I understand McVeigh's loyalty to the Bombers but gee, this surprised me.....

    "The Swans have also retained assistant coach Amon Buchanan and VFL coach Nick Malceski after Mark McVeigh offered them opportunities to join him at Essendon." from this article: Sydney Swans veteran Tom Papley undergoes knee surgery after preliminary final hit

    FFS, bit rich to strengthen your new club at the expense of your old one. Loyalty doesn't last long does it?

    Also from the above article, Paps to undergo surgery on his knee after the "nothing to see here" leg take out against Freo in the prelim. Gee, that rule doesn't seem to apply to the Swans in finals does it?!
    Agreed, it would've decimated our coaching ranks had both Malceski and Buchanan also agreed to join McVeigh at Essendon. This was reported as being on the cards for sometime and no doubt the club had prepared in advance contracts to retain them. Getting & retaining assitants to NSW is difficult with the high COL.

    I thought it was a matter of time before Longmire took up a football position elsewhere, but this timing did surprise everyone. I think the stars lined up in a way that made it to hard for him to refuse. Losing both Buchanan and Malceski would've been more significant, as Horse was not directly involved with the team.

    We still have an assistant vacancy to fill with McVeigh's departure.

    Also agree Paps injury does make a mockery of his non free kick.

    Leave a comment:


  • crackedactor 01
    replied
    Originally posted by stevoswan

    After he knocked back Tassie then North saying he was very happy in Sydney with a new business venture? Wow.....quite strange and a little disappointing.

    Also, I understand McVeigh's loyalty to the Bombers but gee, this surprised me.....

    "The Swans have also retained assistant coach Amon Buchanan and VFL coach Nick Malceski after Mark McVeigh offered them opportunities to join him at Essendon." from this article: Sydney Swans veteran Tom Papley undergoes knee surgery after preliminary final hit

    FFS, bit rich to strengthen your new club at the expense of your old one. Loyalty doesn't last long does it?

    Also from the above article, Paps to undergo surgery on his knee after the "nothing to see here" leg take out against Freo in the prelim. Gee, that rule doesn't seem to apply to the Swans in finals does it?!
    I love what Malceski has been able to do with the VFL team. I would love to see him in the role for at least one more year.

    Leave a comment:

Working...