If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Not sure if this is the thread to post this in but here goes: our season has ended so to the best of my knowledge the sanction period for our 5 is over. The question regarding our B& F is a bit tricky- these boys are eligible for the Brownlow, and Isaac is surely in contention even though Nick Daicos is favoured to win it. So by extension, any of our lads, including the troubled 5 should be eligible for our B & F.
It would be a bit embarrassing if say Isaac would win it but if it then would be given to the next best then it devalues the award. This would present a dilemma for the club and it would take wise heads to find a just solution.
In spite of what happened, and whilst I’m deeply disappointed in him, I think Isaac deserves our medal.
I think Cox said they are back at the start of pre season.
According to Tom Morris, whilst we would like to retain Joel, the club would also be happy to get a first round pick for him. This may explain why we haven't increased our offer.
Logan's breakout form may also have an influence, as he's probably now seen as the no. 2 key forward alongside Charlie.
it is likely down to Joel v McLean. Both have their strengths and weaknesses. Mclean offering the slightly better 2nd ruck option, but would like to see Green develop his goal kicking game to be this option.
In my opinion Joel has far more upside than McLean and is a better forward. I admire McLeans effort, but he struggled as the backup ruckman on Friday night. I would like to see Green given more time as he was impressive in the few games at the end of the season
Tweet
Comment